With clean hands and a clear conscience
January 9, 2008
By Helen Ang
__________________
Fifty years ago, John F. Kennedy was a junior senator at a time when the USA was locked in debate about the direction its immigration policy should take.
In 1958, Kennedy wrote ‘A Nation of Immigrants’ which presents a chronology of the main events in his country’s melting pot history.
It is a timeless essay that observes how the contribution of immigrants could be seen in every aspect of American national life – religion, politics, arts, athletics, entertainment and many other areas.
The monograph was written well before the advent of Rev. Jesse Jackson (candidate for the Democratic presidential nomination in 1984 and ’88)), long before Colin Powell, Condoleeza Rice, Oprah Winfrey, Will Smith, Michael Jordan and of course Obama Barack, currently a frontrunner in the presidential caucus.
Kennedy wrote: “Every ethnic minority, in seeking its own freedom, helped strengthen the fabric of liberty in American life. Similarly, every aspect of the American economy has profited from the contributions of immigrants.”
Immigration reform was a lifelong concern of Kennedy and he returned to the manuscript when he became President. To commemorate its golden anniversary, Harper Perennial reissued the book with a new introduction by Edward Kennedy, hitting American bookshops yesterday. ‘A Nation of Immigrants’ was first published posthumously in 1964 with an introduction by Robert Kennedy.
The ideas contained in JFK’s landmark discourse were ultimately put into practice with the Immigration Bill of 1965, for which his successor President Lyndon B. Johnson gave him full credit.
“Immigration policy should be generous; it should be fair; it should be flexible,” President Kennedy wrote. “With such a policy, we can turn to the world and to our own past, with clean hands and a clear conscience …” His brother, Senator Edward says, “The words he wrote half a century ago ring just as true today.”
We are not immigrants in Malaysia. Last weekend, my family drove to Bukit Tambun (in Penang) where my mother pointed out to us a derelict row of abandoned houses belonging to my great-great grandfather. I’m fifth generation (maybe more) in this country. Yet how am I treated by my government, in effect run by one party which is an anathema to me?
The Kennedy brothers are grandsons of Irish immigrants who began life on an equal footing in the country where they were born.
“This was the secret of America: a nation of people with the fresh memory of old traditions who dared to explore new frontiers, people eager to build lives for themselves in a spacious society that did not restrict their freedom of choice and action,” said this famous grandson of immigrants.
Kennedy had also mused, “American society is a process, not a conclusion”. Those in his country are proud to be American. Are we here all accepted as full and first class proud-to-be Malaysians?
Where is our Bangsa Malaysia?
We’ve been called ‘monyet’ and ‘beruk’ by the PM’s son-in-law. We are truly middle-class monkeys behind the wheels of cartoon ‘national cars’ which crumple from a blow of the sledgehammer … and driving backwards.
Bangsa Malaysia, like American society, is a process. We, civil society, are a rainbow coalition of the nation’s ‘dispossessed and disenfranchised’. Ours is a process to regain our dignity so affronted by the Barisan Nasional. Well, aren’t we indeed dispossessed and disenfranchised in terms of human rights and dignity?
This process must begin now. If not, when?
We are many colours, one dream. Power to the People’s Parliament!





January 9, 2008 at 9:09 pm
Helen Ang needs a blog.
January 9, 2008 at 10:55 pm
Way to go Haris!!! I personally feel many of our leaders have LOST the spirit of ‘bangsa malaysia’.
I still remember Johor MB Abdul Ghani Othman, defended the term ‘ bumiputra’ over ‘bangsa malaysia’and IF am not mistaken he claimed that the term ‘bumiputra’ exclusively belonged to the malay thus this term ‘bangsa malaysia’ just cannot be accepted per se!! I believe he claimed it will also make everybody equal thus the malay would lose their supremacy!! Something to that note…..well this is ONLY ONE malay leader…what about the rest of the goons….???
I truly support whatever campaign that you might undertake/propose to bring about or making this ‘BANGSA MALAYSIA’ a reality right here RIGHT NOW!!!
jan9 ‘09 10.54pm
January 10, 2008 at 12:28 am
well said helen but this is turning to be a POLICE STATE. now, they ( the powers that be thru the police) are going after those that contribute to HINDRAF. whats next? going after the bloggers and those that post comments.
scary aint it? freer society and more democratic space under this false regime?
January 10, 2008 at 3:00 am
The Target been raised and achieved some way
when HR been implanted and exercised with cares in many ways and also many many years non-stop! (US, Canada, EU, Australia and some Asian Countries/areas)
With the kind of EC, cripple Parliament, tricky law-makers, questionable practitioners, courts and judges, sleeping officers and emotional voters!
where to plant or what HR to be planted?
A “Standard” S&P can be non-standard in ALL respects with all “to whom that may concern” being DEAF,
even Rights owners dare not utter a breath!
Clean hand don’t stick
Clear Conscience worry to take!
Any vision of HR being set and being respect?
A Tamah could not work
A condo has no say
Public Park in private hands
Public Common Area under rape!
Private and Officials in hand!
These are homes for all to take their rest!
Show me how, before any next step!
Judge told client to work to bother not his lawyer’s slept!
To plant HR in shits and hell?
A long way, anyone will join to take the first step?
How far Bar work hands in hands?
2000 to say Yes to 3-man panel
only 10 or so to take HR day!
Respect to the 10!!
Sympathy to the 2000 or more!!
Helen, the picture is colorful!!
Do we have the paints to start?
Talking combs to monks instead??
I like the idea very much and working in that direction!
But, experience told me, only Politics People are interested.
To realize and act, ice to summer pests!
I got handful of ice and a handful of summer pests
or worms to be more exact!
January 10, 2008 at 5:47 am
All that was just part of Kennedy’s propaganda tools for his Presidential Election campaign. Is Kennedy really that good?? His death is link to the fact that he nearly drag the entire world into nuclear war during the cold war era with the Soviet Union. A small scape goat was send to eliminate his ‘MADNESS’ before he destroy his very own country.
Still remember how the American treated their Native American and the African American during the 50s, 60s, 70s and 80s??!! Well, we Malaysian are forgetful so I don’t blame you guys. Even now the American are not as ‘united’ as we see.
Words are beautiful and when they form into sentences, they can be persuading, giving you an ILLUSION that will drive you away from REALITY. Please don’t get caught by them easily, an ILLUSION created by them will eventually destroy you in the end. And REALITY is more hasher and cruel then what you can imagine.
The unity problems among Malaysian is more complex then what we can imagine. The ideas from ‘A Nation of Immigrants’ written by JFK can NEVER solve our unity problems. Dig deeper and you will know why! Until the unity problems is solve, Bangsa Malaysia can NEVER be achieve!!
January 10, 2008 at 11:21 am
Kean,
Yes, agree that we have to prioritise “doing”. That’s why I got sucked into People’s Parliament & Hartal. After 2 years of penning some fine rhetoric in Malaysiakini, I felt compelled to at least try & live up to my talk.
I believe PP is a start to the unity thing. I’m Chinese & here am I in this Malay guy’s project (tho’ he’d throw the ball back into our court & say it’s people-driven).
No country is Utopia. But in the space from the American Immigration Bill of 1965, for which credit is given JFK, to 2008 they’ve got Barack Obama (ooops, had a dyslexic moment in the post above & transposed his name) in the run for Prez. When will we get a Chinese as Vice-Chancellor of a public uni … never mind PM.
Whatever Kennedy’s political shortcomings, it was good words he said in his landmark essay — framing ideas for us in an inspirational way. That’s why his words have lived 50 years.
Whereas over here, we’re inundated with bad words. Our Situation Vacant Minister shouts “Bodoh” x nth because its the only flavour Umno knows. But if Nazri is derogatory, MSM is obscenely diobolical & devious. That’s why we need a Boycott.
Btw, I’d replied to you earlier as Comment #47 in our ‘Boycott the newspapers! (1)’ thread — on the seeds of destruction that bad words sow, viz the propaganda sheets in Rwanda inciting genocide.
January 10, 2008 at 11:25 am
Meant 2 years as mKini columnist. I’ve been contributing my writing altogether about 4 years there.
January 10, 2008 at 11:55 am
Hi brother,
I just stop by to say “Selamat Maal Hijrah”.
January 10, 2008 at 2:03 pm
Let’s take our nation back! My favourite phrase since secondary school: f#$& em all and let god sort em out!
cheers
January 10, 2008 at 3:20 pm
I fully support the MSM boycott.I will also support the petition to the advertisers to reduce their exposure in the MSM.From one whole page to half a page. From a colour spread to plain B&W. From daily to thrice a week. The moneysaved can be used to prop up their bottom line or channeled to charity. Those that do so, gets my support and money.
Asking them to stop entirely is wishful thinking and unachievable.I am under no illusion they will change but I must do something on a personal level.Nothing will change IF ONE DOES NOT START WITH ONESELF.
January 10, 2008 at 3:25 pm
Diversity is strength.
January 10, 2008 at 3:47 pm
Helen, I am proud of what you are doing. It is a reflection of our social climate that you remarked about you, a Chinese, being involved in a Malay guy’s project. I yearn for the good old days when the colour of our skins did not matter much.
I wish I could do more. But, while my wife is a slave of the gormen, I can do little. Not hiding behind a pseudonym is the least I can do. I wish to be counted!
To be effective, Hartal has to happen before the GE frenzy. The week allowed for campaigning would be an ideal time.
I await the starter’s gun.
January 10, 2008 at 4:20 pm
SV Singam,
Personally I’m colour blind but you’ve correctly fingered our social climate. An explanation in this thread below.
http://harismibrahim.wordpress.com/2007/09/11/friends-because2/
January 10, 2008 at 4:41 pm
GE is near!
But is EC ready?
http://chinhuatw.wordpress.com/2007/12/31/bersih-more-democracy-and-happiness-in-the-new-year/
Bersih demanded clean & undated Electoral Roll, equal platform, no Postal votes to cut manipulation of disciplinary Forces, 21days period, Administrative Neutral and Reformed Electoral Financing Acts!
Has EC answered why only 1million from 5 million potential new voters done and not the rest?
If others not done, should we rush to elect?
There is time to clean those hands and clear our mind with conscience to better targets before GE should be headed!!
Read the possible dates of GE to come
http://chinhuatw.wordpress.com/2008/01/08/the-son-in-law-should-shut-up-too/
Hope this gives some light to help Helen to put into a better picture for brighter Malaysian to come!!
For same target but with possible many deviations we come
Hope for same target we bring home some essential points to continue the contribution that we can share!!
January 10, 2008 at 7:15 pm
Hello Helen Ang
just to add a bit..
Bobby Jindal won the governor seat of Louisiana(2008)as a republican,A second generation indian.The people of Louisiana(78.45%) voted for his ideas and beliefs not his race.Now, that’s trully being a American.Do you agree?
ciao
January 10, 2008 at 8:51 pm
Summing up my previous post:
1. GE can drag until July 2009.
2. GE without those points raised by BERSIH is running an unfair GE with lot of manipulations.
GE should be delayed unless EC fulfills their obligations to prepare for a fair elections.
-4million potential voters outside the 11million is huge. The correctness of the registered need time and way to check.
-Postal election by disciplinary force not in open ballots as civilians and not Administrative Neutral are blind spots to go.
So help BERSIH to call the attention of all People to insist the above is done. Say one year time more for spreading the idea and let People understand and realize more is a preparation not only for GE but the future to go.
Drag until EC is providing fair situation to Vote!!
January 11, 2008 at 9:46 am
You got a better chance as an Indonesian illegal immigrant to soak in the wealth of Malayisa for your personal pleasure than the true Bangsa Malaysia envisioned here. Just ask Khir Toyo, Menteri Besar of Selangor!! Kennedy was only writing about what he wished to see happen. In Malaysia its already been happening. Just ask Khir Toyo!
January 11, 2008 at 9:56 am
firstly, thanks helen for the article. i believe that words have the power that no gun or sword will ever have on the minds of the people, hence the saying “the pen is mightier than the sword”.
i think right now, what we need most is to be united in our various capacities to do something. there’s nothing worse than dealing with lip service. and for those of us who are not in the frontlines to instigate change, the least we could do would be to support those in the frontlines.
PS: haris, honours even for the 1st leg arsenal vs spurs…. heheh…
January 12, 2008 at 3:59 am
Helen, We, the Chinese Malaysian were consider an OUTSIDER in our very own BIRTH country thanks to our racism government. Being label as ‘KAUM BUKAN BUMIPUTRA’ is enough to strip off our right to enjoy every public facilities which we contribute with our hard earn tax money. Example, public universities, public hospitals, jobs in the government sectors and many more.
So basically we are an ‘IMMIGRANT’ race in Malaysia thanks to the ‘KAUM BUKAN BUMIPUTERA’ label. We complaint about the treatment we get because of this label. We complaint that we are a second class citizen, being treated differently compare to the Malay, the ‘KAUM BUMIPUTERA’.
However, lets face this in REALITY. Who is the real ‘immigrant’ in Malaysia as we label them as ‘PENDATANG ASING’?? Yes, those who came from Indonesia, Philippine, Thailand, Vietnam, Bangladesh, Pakistan and many more countries, both legal and illegally.
Here comes the main blow! HOW DO YOU LOOK UPON THEM? HOW DO YOU TREAT THEM, Helen? Do you sit together with them? Do you eat together with them? Do you chat with them? Do you make friends with them? Will you go out on a ‘date’ with them? Will you allow your children to linger with them? Will you married one of them?
If he/she is a rich immigrant I can assure that many of us will said ‘YES’ to all those questions. However, I’m NOT looking at those rich immigrant, I’m pointing towards the normal immigrant who work as ‘Pekerja Buruh’ at the construction site, factories, plantation sector, maid and many more low income jobs.
These are the immigrants who contribute the most compare to those rich immigrants who came here just to enjoy their life. They do jobs that even we Malaysian DON’T want to do, contribute so much to our country development. Yet, HOW DO WE TREAT THEM??
I won’t deny the fact that I’m one of those people who look at them differently. We can still talk to each other, smile and even greet each other but deep inside my heart, there is something ‘poking’ all the time.
If we can treat these immigrants so differently, how about the other races in Malaysia? See the picture?
That is the REALITY in Malaysia, NO thats not right, I should said HUMAN WORLD. Cruel isn’t it? YES, REALITY IS CRUEL!
Helen, working with Malay or other races doesn’t show your unity with them. I too work in an International company who hire lots of Malay. We work as a team, split our work load and help each other when some one is sick or absent. However, is that unity?
Our unity problem is so complex till I don’t know how to describe it. Lots of factor behind it and even tough we said we want to built a Bangsa Malaysia, but can it become a true Bangsa Malaysia without any prejudice between races?
In front of the stage we can gather and stand unite as one under certain issues but behind the stage, deep inside our heart, no one will know the truth.
Btw, I’m Fidel Castro fan V(^_^). And about Mr. Obama, do you still remember John F. Kerry? Lol, Obama fate will be the same as Kerry, someone will pull the string again. The ‘white’ will make sure their president always be ‘white’.
January 12, 2008 at 10:12 am
MC: To address Martin’s comment,
“…I still remember Johor MB Abdul Ghani Othman, defended the term ‘ bumiputra’ over ‘bangsa malaysia’and IF am not mistaken he claimed that the term ‘bumiputra’ exclusively belonged to the malay thus this term ‘bangsa malaysia’ just cannot be accepted per se!! I believe he claimed it will also make everybody equal thus the malay would lose their supremacy!! …”
MC: Obviously he has not read my article “Malays are not a Race” which clearly describes where they migrated from. In a nutshell, The Australo Melanesians (Orang Asli’s) arrived here 60,000yrs ago. Parameswara, only 600. The Indians (Gujerati Traders) were here 2,000years ago at Lembah Bujang.
MC: To add to that 75% of all “malays” are from Jawa. The majority (4million) arrived when Najib’s Daddy “imported” these Javanese in the 1970’s. Also, in a 1945 poll, there was reported that the Malays only numbered 2.5million then. The problem with a minority ruling class in 1957 is the issue of Apartheid. And that, my friends, is exactly why the “malays” are asked to have their 6.5 children. Unfortunately, by 2011, when all petroleum in Malaysia runs dry, we expect to see a major crisis. Both in terms of economic as well as civil unrest, as Malaysia becomes a net importer of Petroleum. The current rising price per barrel is NOT benefitting us, as all purchases had been “locked” at OLD prices.
If the Corrupt siphoning of Malaysian money continues, I guarantee that chaos will prevail. Just bear in mind that China has the volume of cheap labour which no one else can compare to. And investor will avoid Malaysia on the same note, coz we do not posses the technical expertise on higher-end operations.
Truly Asia Truly Headache.
January 14, 2008 at 4:07 am
Michael Chick, I cannot deny but to fully support and agreed with your comment. Malaysian are forgetful and I can said 95% Human don’t like history lesson or tend to IGNORE it.
However, not only China, we should be aware of India as they are progressing aggressively. In fact, India has 2 advantage over China, they know English well and their cheap labor is EVENT CHEAPER then China. Don’t said India and China, even Vietnam is moving so fast!
If these ‘PENYANGAK’ UMNO and its supporters still in the mood of ’siok sendiri’, only God will know when HELL will be fall upon us.
“KALAU MARUAH BANGSA LEBIH PENTING DARIPADA MASA DEPAN GENERASI YANG AKAN DATANG”, teruskanlah dengan agenda ‘Ketuanan Melayu’ (sorry, I should said KETUANAN UMNO) dan NEP! Teruskanlah sokongan anda kepada UMNO/BN! Jangan menangis apabila satu hari nanti, anak-anak anda MENGEMIS di tepi jalan! Yang ketawa pada akhirnya adalah orang UMNO and putera-puterinya, BUKAN ORANG MELAYU!!