BN’s bizarre bouts of shadow boxing
March 18, 2008
By Helen Ang
________________________
To read mainstream media (MSM), one would have thought that BN had been contesting invisible opponents in the 12th General Election.
The newspapers left hooked, right jabbed and upper cut Barisan Rakyat candidates to the extent of providing more than enough material for a media doctoral thesis. Yet MSM allowed hardly any fair airing to the Opposition they mauled in their bizarre show of silat-boxing.
I shall provide just two examples to encapsulate the above.
Karim Raslan, who is columnist with The Star and The Edge, wrote in the latter publication this week: “I can’t get over the astonishing sight on the TV news of Lim Guan Eng wearing a smart suit, sitting behind a bank of microphones and speaking as the new Chief Minister of Penang. Before that the only time I saw him was as he was either entering or leaving jail. I don’t think I really knew what he looked like.”
If a polished urbanite like corporate lawyer Karim could confess thus, what more the rest of less sophisticated Malaysia caught in the MSM Matrix?
Guan Eng was recently on the front pages (an occurrence as rare as the perfect alignment of our solar system’s nine planets) not because the newspapers ‘bertaubat’ – see the error of their ways and repent – but because the rakyat spoke at the ballot box.
The second instance of BN-MSM shadow boxing concerned Anwar Ibrahim who complained a few days before polling that the Malaysian press launched a “vicious personal attack” against him. Erstwhile Keadilan deputy president Chandra Muzaffar had provided the ammunition for MSM’s open season.
Anwar’s recourse to right of reply was taken in Singapore where he was corporeal to the reporters there, unlike the purported “irrelevance” in his own country.
It’s true that established newspapers in democracies do endorse particular political parties and politicians. However, in Malaysia it goes way beyond acceptable partisanship.
Let’s discuss this further. Today’s Star Online has Samy Vellu commenting “a smaller community like the Indians have to fight for their rights and that could only be done through MIC.” It is his opinion; we may agree or disagree and the paper is of course entitled to publish Samy’s sage saying.
However, Star’s news article ‘Disaster if Anwar is PM’ on March 4 editorialised on Chandra’s remarks that “although Barisan Nasional was flawed, there was no other coalition in the country”. March 8 gave lie to their fairy tale.
Here the paper had colluded with Chandra to tell a bedtime story in Malaysia’s time-honoured tradition.
But now, all the MSM horses and all the MSM men couldn’t put Humpty Dumpty together again (see previous post) because their credibility is in shreds. The egg has cracked; time to fry the omelette with Makkal Sakthi.
This forum is open to discuss the many ways to cook an egg.




March 18, 2008 at 7:27 pm
I have said in my blog and in commentaries that Malaysian Indians do not need political representation. just leave us alone.
I have not been booed at. Joked about. Made fun of. Can account all of the wealth that I have got, although I may not be able to account for how I have lost much of it. And yet i am not quoted.
Samy just lost an election rather embarrassingly. He is booed at and called the vilest of names. He has been proven wrong in his predictions and he cannot account for his wealth. Yet his idiotic statements are headlined and printed as news.
Does that tell something about values of our MSM in this country?
March 18, 2008 at 7:38 pm
The many ways to cook an egg? I don’t mind them any way as long as they’re not poached. Poaching MPs is so unethical, whether they’re bought out or not.
March 18, 2008 at 7:47 pm
Yes Paul Warren, We just got rid of some “Longkang MPs” on the 8th of March, but We have got a long way to go before We can get rid of “Longkang MSM” in this country!
March 18, 2008 at 8:57 pm
The MSM is attempting to give some airtime to the BR teams.. but teasingly scarce and glaringly insincere.
At the same time, they very quickly jump and bloat and gload on any negative news about the BR teams. Their arrogance has not diminished too. Despite the deluge of retorts against the erstwhile Keadilan deputy president just before the elections, the Star still gave him airtime to say his piece on “disaster if Anwar is PM”. Did Star and chandra not witness the same elections we just concluded, or are they reporting from MARS?
They still have not learn…
but will they.. guess not. they are still a leopard.. cant change their spots. No need to discuss how to cook the egg.. its burnt, hapus.. beyond redemption. finito!!
Where we once had BN, we now have BR (Barisan Rakyat)
Where we once had MSM, we now have BR (Berita Rakyat)
Where we once were cowed, we now have BR (Brave Rakyat)
Where we once lost hope, we now have BR (BOLEH! Rakyat)
Lets all read the alternative media. Consign the MSM to oblivion… BOLEH! Rakyat
March 18, 2008 at 9:06 pm
The column in The Edge is not written by Karim Raslan, but crafted by his younger brother, Kam, author of the hugely entertaining Confessions of an Old Boy.
aMiR
March 18, 2008 at 9:14 pm
Has anyone thought of anger. Both BN and MSM are angry if not very angry. They are angry with the oppositions, the rakyat and themselves. Just look how angry LKY is – shouting at DAP, blaming and warning the rakyat of the consequence of their choice. He is also angry at Koh for being a pussy.
What they need now is anger management. So people, keep an eye on them because, people who are angry can do crazy things.
March 18, 2008 at 9:40 pm
Excerp from the article:-
…Star’s news article ‘Disaster if Anwar is PM’ on March 4 editorialised on Chandra’s remarks that “although Barisan Nasional was flawed, there was no other coalition in the country”. March 8 gave lie to their fairy tale…
___________________________________________________________
Dear Haris,
I would imagine Chandra is now banging his balls as PKR’s fortune has changed after 12th GE.
Now Barisan Rakyat may be forming the next government and Anwar Ibrahim become the next Prime Minister.
March 18, 2008 at 9:48 pm
Just stop reading the MSM period.
March 18, 2008 at 9:49 pm
yeah remember YAB Lim Guan Eng went to jail as he tried to fight for the rights of a little Malay girl in his contituency who was raped by her Malay Chief Minister.
Now if Lim Guan Eng is not a Malaysian and has got no respect for Malay rights then who is ?
March 18, 2008 at 10:45 pm
Even with the revealing of the BN cabinets, the fundamentals has not change. The MSM are still government stooges. They will always onslaught the Barisan Rakyat with negative news. The good deed of the BR wakil rakyat will never be known.For this, I always read the MSM with biased. UMNO will never revived and take back the 5 BR states, I fully support DAP,PKR & PAS for next election too just to change 50 years of BN rule. I would like to see BR as Federal government, just for letting them “try”. The first thing once BR be the government is to terminate the licenses of The Star, Utusan, Straits Time Online HAHAHAHA
March 18, 2008 at 10:57 pm
its very confusing period in our history of politic.however from every statement made by bn is not gentlement.one moment bn admit their failure to care for malaysian of all races.the next moment some small fry politician try to tell,the people make a mistake by voting our new goverment in waiting.they can demo without water cannon.can lobby our sultan to allow umno to form minority goverment in perak.very2 confusing.well why not we lobby our beloved agung to allow our goverment in waiting to form a minority goverment in parliment.lets be confuse as bn.whats a joke the bn are.raj raman.race;malaysian.religion my choice.
March 18, 2008 at 11:36 pm
Where have all the Ethic and Professionalism gone?
Souls and Hearts had gone?
Right or Wrong cannot be recalled!
Rules and Procedures only on records
but out of mind of those running dogs!
Justice has $$$$ sign to weigh or Power as an alternative weight!
So Justice had gone!!
Food need time and care to grow
not from oil that shoot from the ground!
Oil money helps the country only if they are for the welfare of the average!
And NOT in the pockets of minority!
Power are Rights and Obligations to work
not for manipulate of the Fairness of ALL!
Fairness are CLOTHES to protect the Average with Rights and Cares!
When they are abused, the Clothes have gone!
Those abusing the Rights are Stripping the Clothes of ALL!
What has left for Malaysians, the Most?
Political B.S. I suppose!!
Professional B.S. to follow!!
Had Election B.S. gone??
TOO BAD, IT’s STILL ON!!
Grievances to be blasted in Blogs?
That’s ALL!!!!!
Echo?
Long time not heard!!
March 18, 2008 at 11:37 pm
ERRATUM:
My apologies to Karim who wrote ‘When voters show who’s the real boss’ in The Star on March 12 http://thestar.com.my/news/story.asp?file=/2008/3/12/focus/20601548&sec=focus
And thanks aMiR for pointing out that I might be dyslexic. Kam Raslan of The Edge it is (quoted in PP post above).
About the eggs now … the idea being floated of ‘Berita Rakyat’ sounds good if it can be concretized to give MSM a run for their money. I’m not anti-newspaper per se, just anti-editorial management as a political appointment.
Some of the rank-and-file journalists would certainly want to do their jobs more professionally if their editors let them & not vet so strenuously.
A further thought is to seriously suggest to the BR controlled states that they do not advertise in MSM.
However, all things considered, the Boycott should proceed in tandem with constructive measures.
March 19, 2008 at 12:15 am
why cook eggs that are rotten? my grandmother always said that it is not a good idea to enlighten the hopeless. let them continue stinking to the high heavens.
as for msm, their days will be numbered if only more marketing practitioners have the sense to see and tap into the potentially powerful alternative media tools. when advertising money trickles elsewhere, only then will msm wake up.
March 19, 2008 at 12:53 am
MSM is that some brand of toilet paper? hmmm… let me check at Tesco…..
March 19, 2008 at 1:20 am
Can somebody (legal practitioners) look into the matter of having state-based papers which I believe is within the ambit of the respective state governments to approve?
With Kelantan, Kedah, Penang, Perak and Selangor governed by BR representatives, the potential outreach is mind-boggling. If the first tsunami was on 8th March ‘08, the ‘Berita Rakyat’ ripples that can be generated from now till GE13 will be truly phenomenal. Especially, when advertisers having a viable alternative is factored in.
P.S. Helen’s dyslexic? Nah! She’s just proven that TPP readers are a discerning lot.
March 19, 2008 at 2:02 am
As far as I’m concerned, Umno-BN is deceased. Finito. R.I.P. Kaput. What happened on March 8th was a Samurai sword that moved so swiftly the 10-headed hydra that has terrorized us for the last 25 years lost all its heads (indeed, absent the MASSIVE CHEATING even Badawi might have lost Kepala Batas, and I’m told it took many busloads of invisible voters to keep Najib’s seat in Pekan). Anyone who hasn’t been brainwashed by establishment pundits with vested interests can see that Anwar has got what it takes to steer this ship back on course. And what it takes is intelligence, courage, stamina, adaptability, good humor, experience, and most importantly, ethical sense. His resilience has been proven over the last ten years by his capacity to transmute tragedy into triumph, transforming himself from victim to victor and all the while maintaining his dignity, clarity, and focus. Whatever his early political agenda, the Anwar Ibrahim of 2008 has been forged in the furnace of personal pain and endurance.
In 1998 he could have taken the money and run – become an academic or corporate CEO. But he didn’t. He stood up to Mahathir and fought like a man. That’s how he gained my respect and admiration and trust. There are very few in our midst today that I can describe as “heroic.” Is Chandra Muzaffar a hero? He might have been once, back in the early 1980s when he left academia to battle the monstrous menace of Mahathir. But after his ISA experience in 1987, Chandra’s spirit buckled. He left Aliran to establish JUST and for a few years he continued to say the right things. But he had lost his fire, his fighting spirit. He had gone the way of Lee Lam Thye. Is Tian Chua a hero? I would say YES!
But his career as a politician is only just beginning. Even so, his fearlessness in the face of police violence has inspired many to speak up or march for justice. There are many heroes I can think of – and they are all in the Barisan Rakyat. But to my mind nobody can match what Anwar Ibrahim has accomplished:
he has led us through the Chapel Perilous of racial politics and now, for the first time since Merdeka, we can look around and appreciate the beauty of our own diversity and say, “Vive la difference!” On March 9th I was blissed out by a tangible feeling that we are no longer stuck in the rut of ethnocentric tempurungism, that we have finally outgrown all that “Bangsa-Ugama=Tanahair” hot air. I went to town and felt the genuine goodwill and jubilation that shone from every face I saw – Malay, Chinese, Indian, Danlainlain! What has been missing all these decades is
the possibility that we can love one another as humans, regardless of skin color or creed – that’s because cold-blooded ambition and ruthless greed have no use for empathy and warm feelings, it does not encourage compassion, kindness, and spontaneous joy. No, it feeds and fattens itself vampire-like on fear – other people’s fear. And now, on that bright Sunday morning after GE12, that fear had dissipated like a bad smell in the winds of change. In the climate of fear Mahathir created during his 22-year reign, anybody who dared speak the truth became a hero. Anwar Ibrahim, more than any other political icon in the country, succeeded in transcending his own childhood prejudices to embody the universal values that will unite rather than divide us as a nation. That is indeed the mark of a hero. Let us honor this hero by giving him what he fully deserves – the chance to serve as prime minister. At the same time, let us all aspire to become heroes too, so that we will no longer be scared children in need of a grown-up to lead us across the street. Let us each become, in time, self-governing individuals whose relationship to political leaders is akin to an orchestra’s respect for the conductor, knowing full well that his job is to create a symphony from the cacophony of so many different instruments.
March 19, 2008 at 4:16 am
Dedicated to the editors and journalists of MSM.
YOU WERE MEANT FOR THE SKIES
This story reminds us how important a healthy self image really is.
A man found an eagle’s egg and put it in a nest of a
barnyard hen. The eagle hatched with the brood of chicks and grew up with them. All his life, the eagle did what the barnyard chicks did, thinking he was a barnyard chicken. He scratched the earth for worms and insects. He clucked and cackled. And he thrashed his wings and flew a few feet in the air.
Years passed and the eagle grew very old. One day he saw a magnificent bird above him in the cloudless sky. It glided in graceful majesty among powerful wind currents, with scarcely a beat of its strong, golden wings.
The old eagle looked up in awe. “Who’s that?” he asked.
“That’s the eagle, the king of the birds,” said his neighbor. “He belongs to the sky. We belong to the earth ?? We’re chickens.” So the eagle lived and died a chicken, for that is what he thought he was.
You were meant for the skies – not the chicken coop. Who
will believe in you if you do not believe in yourself?
TRUTH
Be generous in prosperity, and thankful in adversity. Be fair in thy judgment, and guarded in thy speech. Be a lamp unto those who walk in darkness, and a home to the stranger. Be eyes to the blind, and a guiding light unto the feet of the erring. Be a breath of life to the body of humankind, a dew to the soil of the human heart, and a fruit upon the tree of humility.
- Author Unknown
STRENGTH & COURAGE
You gain strength, courage and confidence by every experience in which you really stop to look fear in the face. You are able to say to yourself, ‘I have lived through this horror. I can take the next thing that comes along.’ You must do the thing you think you cannot do.
- Eleanor Roosevelt
Be true to urself, god and others.
March 19, 2008 at 8:27 am
Who cares about MSM anymore? I only glance through once per week, either for the Job recruitment page or what’s hot this weekend. Even TV is for entertainment, not news. I remember during an early morning TV1 news, the newscaster is asking people to vote for BN, wonder how much he is being paid to do so!!!
March 19, 2008 at 8:29 am
i stopped buying papers..
March 19, 2008 at 8:48 am
I had stopped reading the MSM sometime in Feb. Terminated my morning delivery of NST & Star. Only one I felt sorry for was the newspaper vendor as I had reduced his income somewhat. I would rather read the international papers online and the alternate media. I don’t think I have missed anything of importance or relevance by not reading the MSM.
Before March 8 I was in despair of the situation in our country. I felt unwanted and a second class citizen – I am not Chinese or Indian but one of the minorities classified as “others”. Still the words of UMNO hurt when all the negative comments were made at the past UMNO AGMs. I voted for the opposition and truth be told I did it because anyone is better than BN. I am glad I did. The results of the March 8 GE have given me so much hope for the future of our country. The BR may have their ups and downs but I believe that they are the way of the future for Malaysia.
March 19, 2008 at 8:53 am
i didnt buy my Star and NST again today. Three days in a row !!!
Malaysiakini Boleh !
March 19, 2008 at 10:23 am
i used the msm papers for my dogs to pee and poo on!
March 19, 2008 at 10:30 am
Dear Writer,
Please get your fact straight.
Karim Raslan, who is columnist with The Star and The Edge, wrote in the latter publication this week: “I can’t get over the astonishing sight on the TV news of Lim Guan Eng wearing a smart suit, sitting behind a bank of microphones and speaking as the new Chief Minister of Penang. Before that the only time I saw him was as he was either entering or leaving jail. I don’t think I really knew what he looked like.”
If a polished urbanite like corporate lawyer Karim could confess thus, what more the rest of less sophisticated Malaysia caught in the MSM Matrix?
This was written by Karim Raslan……Kamraslan wrote this in TheEdge on march 17 2008 in his columm Talking Edge. please ractify that….thanks..mrich
March 19, 2008 at 10:50 am
This is the story
Spinning tales and (mis)adventures
Cooking all types of eggs
Pick a choice taste it
The editors want a living
Posh homes money to spend
Forget about dignity and honesty
In the world of businesses
They can’t sink so low
So the editors thunder
Across the spread in their newspapers
Bashing the poor fellows
Taking pride in their tirades
Giving biased analysis
Asking well connected people for views
Always that subtleness betraying their souls
About money flowing with greed
No chances for the other party
In the blogs the new waves hit back
Denouncing the biased reporting
Hitting it in cyber-space
The magic flow smoothly
In their hearts they know
Don’t follow; no job to show
No food on the table
It is still the bread and butter issues
They say it; they know it
So they pretend writing differently
Sell their souls forget their principles
It is why there is no fairness
When one sells one’s soul away
March 19, 2008 at 11:55 am
After all of Haris’ vitriol on MSM, he would appear on The Star forum. What is he trying to tell us? Will he wear that silly t-shirt to the forum?
Politics is the art of the possible – Otto Von Bismarck (1867)
March 19, 2008 at 12:13 pm
Please ignore the last paragraph…it should read
This was NOT written by Karim Raslan……Kamraslan wrote this in TheEdge on march 17 2008 in his columm Talking Edge. please ractify that….thanks..mrich
March 19, 2008 at 12:29 pm
What is “acceptable partisanship”. I don’t think you will find the Straits Times writing anything negative about the govt that does not have the govt approval. We just need more newspapers.
When the Star first went national, it was viewed that their reporting is more balance so I buy Star with NST. Over time, I stopped buying NST. I am waiting to subscribe to another local english newspaper.
March 19, 2008 at 1:05 pm
wow, antares, you took the very words from me – well-strung!
March 19, 2008 at 1:52 pm
I believe the BN egg is already in self-destruct. We’d best leave it alone and stay as far away as possible to avoid the fallout.
I am most apprehensive about Anwar courting BN deserters. They may enable his ascendency but I fear they will infect the PKR with a deadly disease.
It is urgently critical that DAP and PAS address and resolve whatever issues that linger between them so that they don’t depend on PKR as a glue anymore.
All BR parties must stop referring to the individual races and begin to speak of Anak Bangsa Malaysia. All of their programs must be framed IRRESPECTIVE OF RACE!!!
Old habits are hard to lose so we have to keep reminding them.
March 19, 2008 at 11:07 pm
just about getting fed-up about all the comments on boycott of the MSM. All i have to say is that JUST DO IT. FIXED IT AND GIVE THESE LIARS A KICK AS GOOD AS WE CAN GIVE.
Goodnite.
March 19, 2008 at 11:52 pm
IS MSM THE MOST IRRESPONSIBLE?
==============================
An Healthy Society needs Healthy MSM
Under the world of BN, most are not Healthy!
Can we have some blue skies from the 5 States for an Alternative Healthy MSM?
So, it will give a Mirror as well as a step for taking over others when needed!
Unhealthy MSM up to today have to be accounted because they are forced to be unhealthy under BN!
Unlike lawyers that I experienced, they are not forced to be unhealthy
but they want to be unhealthy to drag and leave space for other lawyers to continue as crooks dragging case for years with the help of the Court!
In compare, MSM have more excuse than those crooked lawyers who are under their own control!!
When Ethics of Lawyers are well specified in the LPA!
If Bar is not closing their eyes as well, can those crooked lawyers exist for so many years – 10-30 years !!
Fighting Bad lawyers are even worse than fight BN, Folks!!
April 5, 2008 at 2:13 pm
hi harris,
just to clarify, karim raslan did not write this article in the edge. it was his brother Kam.
thanks