many-colours-114When I read Rocky’s post entitled ‘Malaysia’s Obama, according to Bakri Musa’, where Rocky quotes Bakri as saying that ‘Malaysia already has her Barack Obama in the person of Mahathir Mohamed’, the first thing that came to mind was there was someone in cyberspace impersonating that good surgeon.

Then I read Bakri’s article in full in Rocky’s other blog, laughed out loud and thought to myself, ‘Good one, Rocky’.

Yes, you must take the cue from Rocky and read Bakri’s piece in full.

I’ll just reproduce below the lines that immediately follow where Rocky left off with the above quote from Bakri.

We do not recognize him as such because unlike in America where its Obama is considered a member of the minority, Malaysia’s majority Malays warmly and quickly embrace their Obama as one of their own. Nor is Mahathir alone; earlier leaders like Datuk Onn and Tunku Abdul Rahman also had mixed ancestry.                                                                                                                             By biological heritage, Obama has equal claim to being black or white. Yet because of his unalterable physical characteristics Obama is labeled black. Even if Obama were to resort to the miracles of plastic surgery, skin-whitening cream, and hair coloring and straightening a la Michael Jackson, which Obama does not, he would still be labeled black.

For contrast, examine the group portrait of UMNO Supreme Council members. If they were to dispense with their songkok and Baju Melayu and instead put on modern attire, some of them could easily be mistaken as delegates from MCA or MIC, that is, until they open their big mouth and chant their chauvinistic slogan of Ketuanan Melayu!

Now I’ll take you to the part that was, for me, at least, telling.

…However, if we dispense with the racial label and ask the more substantive question of whether Malaysia could produce a future leader the caliber and transforming character of Barack Obama, then the answer is more complex and problematic.       Obama captures the imagination of Americans with his brilliance, eloquence, and charisma. He appeals to their finer instincts; he brings Americans together, transcending class, region, and most of all, race.

Have I misunderstood Bakri?



38 Responses to “…but a not so wholesome Obama, Bakri seems to suggest”

  1. matt Says:

    The way i look at it,it was all about mamaks who have deceived the true bumis in Malaysia and becoming their leader.

  2. Kinsyng Says:

    I do not know whether you have misunderstood Bakri or not, then again, if I didn’t misunderstand Bakri myself…, here’s my thought on it.

    To have Bakri said that Malaysia’s version of Obama is Mahathir is akin to Koh Tsu Koon suggesting that Badawi should carry the title, “Bapa Demokrasi”

    Have I misunderstood Bakri?

  3. yh Says:

    haris,

    its no longer the same rocky. he is now all for mahatirism, like it or not.

  4. ian Says:

    Mathematical Proof that Mahathirism is Evil:

    http://iwfrpk.blogspot.com/2008/11/mathematical-proof-that-mahathirism-is.html

    REJECT FASCIST GOVERNMENT, REJECT MAHATHIRISM, REJECT ISA.

  5. Hartal MSM Says:

    While we don’t know if Mahathir can speak Malayalee, much is made of the fact that Obama can’t speak a word of Swahili (or any other native African tongue) – extract as posted by Rocky.

    The Rocky types then throw the gauntlet for Malaysian minorities lauding Obama’s election to start speaking BM [parallel to Obama speaking the majoritarian English language].

    BM is cultivated in school. For starters, the Leadership-by-Example should perhaps withdraw their kids from international school and enrolling them in national school. What does it tell us when the scions of Umno speak English first and foremost? The usual double standards?

  6. LChuah Says:

    URGENT

    Sorry to use this space to inform M-T readers that the website seemed to have been blocked. Since most people tend to get schedules of events, such as this Sunday’s vigil, from M-T, perhaps fellow bloggers can synchronize the announcements of events, news, etc. so as to reach the greatest number of people.

    Any other suggestions?

    LChuah

  7. LChuah Says:

    Hi, M-T returned a while ago – could be the website’s down for maintenance. Sorry for wasting space here.

    Regarding Rocky’s articles, I’d stopped scanning them some time ago, when it was obvious that he wrote in order to be noticed, and hoped that when noticed he’d get some cushy job, possibly at NST. Sad, but quite a common trait these days.

  8. clearwater Says:

    Haris,

    You are more like the wholesome Obama that appeals to our finer instincts than Mahathir who appeals to those with baser beliefs. No, we have not have had an Obama and is unlikely to have one anytime soon. Our current political system and divisions will ensure that.

  9. abil Says:

    We need to completely study the whole article to understand the auther’s intention. Reading pieces selected by bloggers often fail to give complete picture, hence a good lesson to all our readers to go to source of the article and then to comment would be my advice.Mahathir is unlike Obama because Mahathir divides and rules and uses race as his tool, where Obama tries to unite Americans through diversity.Mahathir hides his ancestry, wherelse Obama is proud of his ancestry as a mixed person. It is very defining moment in the histroy of Americans to have transend the race barrier. I am sure Americans would have accepted Mandela as a President, had he been an American for his goodness and non racial thinking.

  10. Thurai Says:

    Yes, you did and SO DID I! :-)

  11. Paul Warren Says:

    BARACK OBAMA – MALAYSIA’S ENEMY NO 1!

    That is what I wrote on 6th Nov. Funny, for first time I got a few comments.

    Obama represents an “in your face” proposition to the UMNO led Barisan Nasional, isn’t it?

    Everything that the UMNO led Barisan Nasional represents you will find the Ku Klux Klan having upheld. UMNO’s leaders sound like a KKK broken record most times when they screech “ketuanan Melayu” In case they don’t know, after Hitler and his Nazi attempt at championing the supremacy of the Aryan race, the next guys who went about championing the supremacy of their race was the KKK.

    In case you guys are thinking about South Africa, that was another cattle of fish. It did not seem like they were championing the supremacy of their race, it was more like they were treating the blacks in South Africa as scum of the earth to be trodden upon. After all they seemed willing to be equals to the Jews and the rest of Europe and who ever else who will deal with them. Sounds more like they were willing to share out the claim to supremacy.

    I read a bit of Bakri Musa’s article, just that I thought he was chiding rather than making a serious commentary. Mahathir, Malaysia’s Obama?

    Obama represents the actualisation and the realisation of Martin Luther King’s dream. What does Mahathir represent?

  12. A L Wong Says:

    To me,people like Haris,RPK,LGE, Zorro,are as close to an Obama as we can ever get.
    All you you promote universal values and try to bring Malaysian together !!
    All of you have inspired me to get off my couch and, after 51 yrs of apathy, take an active interest in the future of our beloved Malaysia.

  13. JOHJ Says:

    Yes, Malaysian looked alike, the only difference is their names in their MYKAD. In Kelantan, you will never notice the difference between Chinese and Malays when they converse in Malay, and even have similiar cultures. Even between chinese and chinese, they converse in BM local dialect. When it comes to rights, they are separated into bumi and non-bumi, muslim and non-muslim. Forget about Barrack Obama in Malaysia.

  14. gerakilat Says:

    yh Says:
    November 14, 2008 at 11:27 pm

    haris,

    its no longer the same rocky. he is now all for mahatirism, like it or not
    =======================================
    Couldn’t agree more with yh, haris. Rocky now sings a different tune. My hunch is that he wants to be the next kalimullah of NST, but with Najib as his bossff, and since Najib supports Mahathirism, Rocky is obliged to expound it.Rocky is increasingly becoming a “pengkhianat” to the blogging fraternity

  15. wan Says:

    well done, haris!

    Rocky’s post, a cunning partial excerpt of Bakri Musa’s most excellent article, is an oft-used but still effective tactic in media spinning, long a hallmark of UMNO/BN controlled papers.

    This particular post of yours has an effect of countering his spin to mislead his readers. It is most instructional in the sense that it has spotlighted what is essentially a shrewd (albeit unethical)tactic, often practised by UMNO/BN controlled media to mislead the public.

    Rocky’s post certainly exemplifies the fact that old and ingrained habits die hard.

    Clearly we can also count on “The People’s Parliament” blog to also act as media monitor to illuminate such unprofessional journalistic tactics that has accompanied the migration of many MSM journalists to cybersphere.

    -wan-

  16. Nanda Says:

    Yeah, ‘Good one, Rocky’ indeed. Taking a sentence from an article and using it to cast the entire article in a different light. Nicely done.

  17. amoker Says:

    haha. Rocky is trying to show off his spinning skills to his future masters in NST or Utusan.

    He used to have credibility in his postings. I guess NST would drop their suit soon.

    Is Mahathir the same as Obama ? BOth are different man except that one has gone very rich. hehe

  18. dinobeano Says:

    Haris, I received that article directly from Bakri via e-mail. After reading it, I emailed him to say that Mahathir is not Obama, but Orang Lama who reverted to his old ultra-Malay mindset. I was surprised that Bakri cannot see Mahathir for what he really—a bitter from Prime Minister with vengeance on his mind, whatever the means.Unfortunately, Bakri did not respond to that e-mail, which also copied Azly Rahman at Columbia University, New York.

    As for Rocky Bru, he has sold out to the other side. He has his self interest to take care of. —Din Merican

  19. CPK Says:

    Hahahahahahaha……gasp, splutter…….hahahahaha….

    Laughter is good for the soul – I MIGHT just start checking in on Rocky again every once in a while…..

    …….hahahaha….choke….hahahahaha………..

  20. cresma Says:

    that is why non of the PKR leaders can be the obama of malaysia (if we follow what bakri musa dictates).

    most of them are racist and think only about their own race. LKS and Karpal Singh are so anti Malay.

    Anwar is so ultra malay.

    the rest are either pro islam or anti malay.

  21. jrajster Says:

    I’m equally puzzled like any other readers here. Rocky seems to have different agenda for himself. In most of his writings he has hidden opinions if one carefully reads.

    Perhaps it’s all because of TDM’s personal congratulatory remarks to Rocky. If continues to be the way he is doing now very soon he may see no visitors to his blog.


  22. The way I see it

    If my dad is an Indian then I would consider myself an Indian too. If my dad is a Chinese then I would consider myself Chinese too and so if my dad is a Malay I would consider myself Malay too. Shouldn’t we follow our dad regardless of whatever race my mum is?God created Adam first and so rightfully we follow our dads. How is it that Mahathir who has an Indian dad does not consider himself Indian? I pity his dad.

    Barack Obama has a Kenyan dad and so he considers himself black eventhough his mum is white. I think he is on the right track :)

    Well that’s my 2cents worth opinion .

  23. alice Says:

    The way I see it

    If my dad is an Indian then I would consider myself an Indian too. If my dad is a Chinese then I would consider myself Chinese too and so if my dad is a Malay I would consider myself Malay too. Shouldn’t we follow our dad regardless of whatever race my mum is?God created Adam first and so rightfully we follow our dads. How is it that Mahathir who has an Indian dad does not consider himself Indian? I pity his dad.

    Barack Obama has a Kenyan dad and so he considers himself black eventhough his mum is white. I think he is on the right track

    Well that’s my 2cents worth opinion .

  24. V Says:

    You people still read rockybru, o thats a bad way to spend your weekends. Nowadays, his writtings are too ‘obvious’.

  25. casper Says:

    Kinsyng – Bakri is known to put on the wrong hat. Early days of MT he mouthed off, M’sian Chinese often employ Indonesian maids only to exploit, abuse and make slaves out of them. Bakri didn’t realise Home Ministry and agent have a monopoly with permits, M’sians can employ candidates of their choosing.

    And as for Badawi – “Bapa Demokrasi”, I think not but rather Badawi – Datuk kahwin lagi !!!! You can qoute me on that and feel free to spread the word.

    Regards kinsyng, Haris and all

  26. casper Says:

    Hartal MSM

    Here is a posting I chance upon. A friend of mine was playing me a song from a P2P network. She was taken a back with commentaries – after all it was a music forum(Indon indie vs M’sian indie bands) with choice words flying about that went on and on. Here is a sample that might prove amusing with regards to them office bearers in UMNO.

    [alengier (3 days ago) Show Hide
    0 Poor comment Good comment
    Marked as spam
    Reply | Spam
    tipikal jenis melayu.. bahasa nak inggeris.. baju nak kot..makan nak chinese.. drama nak venezuela.. filem nak hindustan.. band nak indon.. ulama nak arab..
    inilah akibatnya lama sangat kena jajah..dah hilang jatidiri.. bangsat jer memanjang.. bongok betul...
    tunggu hari pancasila menjajah]

    Regard as humour but the last remark(Pancasila) is just caution. It is forecast, by the year 2050 present minorities namely Spanish speaking citizens, would form the majority in the States. We are not far off in M’sia and if UMNO’s rein persist, we might jolly well have a Premier with very close ties to Indonesia while non-Muslims ‘pendatang’ experience apartheid.

    The emphasis on pendatang, kaum asing or penunggu and all its variants was often central to Dr.M’s fork tongue when stirring up his congregation of monkeys. The old man’s language is even more vile lately with his ‘penunggu’ remark. Note the difference ie ‘pendatang’ means migrants while ‘penunggu’ refers to squatters.

    Talk about double standards par excellence, there is no letting up that twisted conniving evil mind of the old man.

    Regards.

  27. farida Says:

    Rocky has clearly thrown his full support behind MSM because he displays so clearly the traits of spinning. Poor Bakri, to have his article abused through cunning extraction!

  28. Hartal MSM Says:

    Thanks Casper,

    There’s a seriously disturbing blog ‘Demi Negara’ i think People’s Parliament readers should check out. His claim to fame was his ‘RPK Mystique’ posting.

    For a pseudonymous blog (blogger name is Kijang Mas) started only in Sept, the post below got 172 comments.
    http://deminegara.blogspot.com/2008/10/in-conversation-with-robin-serial-on.html

    The alarming postings (also read Kijang Mas in his Comment section rejoinders) whipping up race sentiments are getting traffic channeled from the established pro-Umno, pro-Dr M blogs.

  29. Unmask Rocky Says:

    Bernard Khoo would like to live up to his blogname “Zorro Unmasked” and unmask RockyBru for what he really is!

  30. tkterimakasih Says:

    Ever since rocky went on strike with marina,i thought he lost his spine.
    Bakri Musa made it quite clear that mahathiur is NO Obama.
    SPIN,SPIN,SPIN,
    I wonder if our good surgeon is amused!

  31. mickey Says:

    In other words, Obama is the mamak to what Mahathir to Malaysia.

    Skin colour, origins does not matter. What matters is whom the majority accepts.

    We coloured people had ruled Malaya over 50 years ago.

    what’s the issue?

  32. Sadar Says:

    President elect Barack Hussein Obama were not chosen to became the country 44th president because of the color of his skin , but because of the party he represent i.e Democrats.

    Ironically Osama became the president of the now defunct Taliban goverment of Afghanistan by sending opposition dissident to Gulags and beheadings .

    Which of the above individual have more similiarity to Dr Mahathir? You guess is as good as mine.

  33. navinda Says:

    Rocky has been for some time now become champion of Mahathir. Mahathir’s only claim to be an “Obama” for Malaysia is his mixed parentage. But his divide and rule policies, and his championing Ketuanan Melayu refutes any such claims.
    Grow up Rocky. We are not kids to be led by the nose. We will not equate Mahathir with Obama. Its an insult to Obama.

  34. rajan Says:

    Hey Bruder Harris,
    Its nothing new about him, He was kicked out ,of course with a hefty payment due to him, Once its all gone, Well, try to get back in, so, main belakang lah bruder.
    I knew from the start, he is the snake in the lallang.
    Mahatir, when he was out , nothing , now in the game plan, with kali out, he wants in.
    AHHHHHhhhhhhhhh ROCKKKKKKKKKKkkkkkkkkk it.
    He sold out bruder. READ all his postings, yes, read all his postings after AAB gave in, he started praising, carrying, polishing balls etc etc
    What can i sayyyyy OBAMAAAAAAAAAA ? Who ? MAHATIR ?????????????????????????????????? Mahatir is going to wreak havoc soonnnnnnnnnnnnn
    Cheers with Rock hahaha

  35. Leithaisor Says:

    Whatever happened to journalists being professionals who reported the news objectively and honestly?

    The advisor to the National Press Club,Protem President of the National Alliance of Bloggers and once-Malay Mail Big Gun now being repeatedly accused of hihgly selective quoting and spin doctoring?

    What next? A motion to pecat him by Press Club members? Or an announcement by an UMNO-linked newspaper that Rocky has been appointed to a plum job as oft mentioned by many?

    The bottom line is in one’s words and deeds, and the people will see what a person really stands for.

  36. Shout9 Says:

    Kiasu’s constant want-all, and Macha’s non ending self-pity theaterics proving to be a good lesson to the Malays. Malays now see that they get bashing for nothing when in fact, they have already been doing the OBAMA even before Parameswara . The USA took 250 yrs to do it. After 1957, (*there was no Merdeka actually, because the Rulers were there all the time even before Cheng Ho dropped in)- it was the Part-siamese/Part-Bugis/Part-Turkish/Part Indian/Part Chinese and soon Part Bugis again Political power play.

    But, hey, their real racist Chinese Indian Others Brothers (called (x)Malaysian or Malaysian(x)?!) are unwittingly teaching Malays about colors-now they have to show theirs too. Being the passive majority they start to realise Malaysia was not called ‘Malay’sia for no reason….hmmmm?
    Think about this the next time you start cursing.

    PEACE…(it’s a choice)

  37. Benjamin Loi Says:

    Dear Dr. Bakri Musa:
    As a faithful “follower” of your weekly articles, i would like to hightlight some points you mentioned in your article:

    1. Contrast that to Malaysia. There are many children of Malay-Caucasian as well as Malay-Chinese and Malay-Indian marriages exhibiting very “un-Malay” features. Yet Malay culture has been very welcoming of them, unhesitatingly embracing them as Malays. This is not a recent phenomenon. I had many childhood friends and classmates who had distinctly Chinese or Indian appearances because of adoption or mixed marriages, yet they were all considered and treated as Malays.

    Why the children of mixed marriages between a member of the majority and a minority are not regarded as the majority in America, but they are in Malaysia, is an observation worth pondering. I am certain this is related to an underlying obsession with “racial purity.”

    – I had a worker from Bangladesh who married a Malay girl 13 years ago, they had 3 kids and to my very surprised, their kids are Malays so they are “bumiputra”. Yes, without doubt, if you are a Muslim and follow the Malay customs, you can become a Malay and the society welcomes you and wholeheartedly accepts you, but if we think deeper, 1. why those people who very much want to be Malays in the first place? 2. why Malay society unhesitantly embrace them as Malays?
    My Answer to question No 1: It is the benefits and privileges they are seeking after, we have many indian-Malays in Penang and Kedah who would do anything to prove that they are more Malay than Malay! My former Bangladeshi worker is doing likewise, I can’t believe a foreign worker can father 3 Malay kids, but his children birth certificates are real! Malaysia government is taking the UK prodigy Suffiah as Malay, that’s why our government provided her with full-scholarship. Americans are living in truth-”you’re what you’re, you don’t have to be what we are in order to achieve what you want to be”. Your article seems to propose that Malay society is more “inclusive”, but this “inclusiveness” stems from a feeling of “insecure” and is geared towards the goal of elimination of other culture, language, race etc, to ensure there is only 1 race-Malay in the soil of our land. This “inclusiveness” – derived from the “exclusiveness” mentality harboured by narrow-minded Malays won’t encourage the cultivation of genuine racial tolerance and would be a barrier for the healthy development of multi-racial society. If i were a Bugis or Minangkabau or Orang Java in Malaysia, I should be proud of my heritage and shouldn’t be subjected to enormous amount of pressure for acknowledging my roots and my ancestral history.

    My answer to question No 2:
    Is it true that Malay society will unhesitantly embrace someone who claims to profess Islamic faith and follow the Malay customs-”way of life” ?? Let’s examine it from a Sociologist’s perspective, let’s look at this hypothetical assumption — if all the Chinese and Indian were to become Muslims and speak only Malay starting from tomorrow, do you think we would have only one Malay race in 3-5 years time? The answer is an emphatic NO. Why? Unless the Malay society is very progressive, otherwise they will once against point their finger at “Chinese-Malay” for dominating Malaysia economy and politics, it is possible in Thailand and Indonesia because they only have less than 3% Chinese in their total population. If all the Indians in Malaysia were to become Muslims, Mahathir won’t be able to become our Prime Minister…why? Please read my article:
    http://benjaminloi.blogspot.com/2008/09/dr-mahathir-i-hope-youre-not-racist.html


Leave a Reply