Constitutional amendments carried through at the recently concluded UMNO assembly were touted as intended to address the problem of money politics that had long plagued the party’s elections.
Whether those amendments will in fact achieve that stated objective remains to be seen.
And if such amendments prove to be effective, one wonders if PKR, too, is up to the task of doing whatever is necessary to rid itself of the cancerous money politics that has, in recent days, become the order of the day in Sabah.
No, not vote-buying but, so my source tells me, buying acquiescence and submission, at divisional head level, of the most recent decision made at Merchant Square with regard to the state level leadership.
NSTonline reported last Saturday that new Sabah PKR state chief, Thamrin, claimed that 17 division chiefs or their representatives had attended the first meeting chaired by him the day before and were all supportive of his leadership of PKR Sabah.
Someone who was at the meeting assures me that Thamrin’s claim is pure fiction.
“Divisional heads who were in attendance were Thamrin for Libaran, Kudat’s Mursalim, Johani Abd Halim of Silam, Kalabakan’s Datuk Dr. Amir, Ghani Medeh of Kinabatangan, Tuaran’s Ansari, Datuk Kong of Tawau and Ranau’s Jonathan Yasin. Thamrin may lay claim to have the support of these seven, though that is seriously debatable”, my source disclosed over the phone.
“It would be a joke, though, to suggest that Hj. Ag Tangah of Kimanis and Jalumin Samin of Kota Belud who also attended the meeting lent their support to the new state leadership”, the source continued.
“Division chiefs who did not attend were that of Keningau, Kota Kinabalu, Tenom, Pensiangan, Beluran, Batu Sapi, Semporna, Beaufort, Papar, Penampang and Putatan. Representatives, in place of some division heads, attended for Sepanggar, Kota Kinabalu, Papar and Sipitang”, my source detailed.
Word on the ground, my source went on, is that more and more, Thamrin is seen as a mere puppet who dances to the tune played by yet another Anwar loyalist, Ansari.
“Ansari is calling the shots. Thamrin hasn’t a clue of what is going on.”, my source explained.
“During the pc after his meeting, Thamrin denied allegations that his predecessor, Azmin Ali, had been undemocratic in settling the matter of his replacement. Do you know that in earlier meetings, before his appointment, Thamrin was most critical of Azmin? Ask the other division chiefs privately, and they will tell you the same. If you’re going to ask, though, it better be soon because a lot of money is being tossed about in the hope of buying support for a decision by HQ that is beginning to turn into a nightmare that KL never imagined would happen. Papar division has already held a meeting to dissolve the division and more will follow unless the problem created by the appointment of Thamrin in total disregard of local sentiment is corrected. Buying the support of divisions will allow some people in KL to save face.”, my source went on.
I said that as far as I knew, PKR wasn’t exactly rolling in money, so who was funding this, if indeed this was true.
“A filthy rich Dato Gulam who is related to the Chief Minister is also very closely connected to Ansari. You can figure the rest yourself, I’m sure. The funny thing is that, in an attempt to discredit Jeffrey, rumours have been spread that he might be a BN plant. For many of us over here in Sabah PKR, it’s becoming more and more obvious who that plant might be.”, the source replied.
“Another rumour that appears to be coming out of KL, to try and justify bypassing Jeffrey as state chief, is that Jeffrey was in discussions with other parties in Sabah well before the decision to appoint Thamrin was made, and these people are pointing to the so-called hush-hush talks that are supposed to have taken place between Jeffrey and Yong of SAPP recently as evidence of this. For this reason, so the story goes, Jeffrey could not, in the interest of Sabah, be appointed.”
“KL must understand that Sabah politicians have long learned not to completely trust their counterparts from Semenanjung. And so Sabah politicians will continue to talk with each other, to put in contingencies, just in case KL politicians live up to their reputation. True enough, see what happened in Sabah? First, Azmin appointed without any consultation with the locals. Then the choice of the locals as replacement for Azmin completely disregarded by KL.”
“Now there’s talk that Jeffrey is either going to join PBS or one of the other parties. Not true. You wait and see. He’s going to get a new outfit off the ground. One that will definitely be able to work with the other local parties. And that will spell the end of PKR in Sabah.”, my source continued.
I suggested that if the opposition was to have any chance of knocking BN out at the federal level at the next GE, surely there would be need for some sort of real collaboration between politicians in Semenanjung and East Malaysia. Someone would have to take the lead, be it from Semenanjung or Sabah or Sarawak. Was it the case that East Malaysians were unprepared to have someone from KL lead them, I asked.
“For now, Zaid appears to have left a favourable impression with us. Mind you, he is from KL, so even Zaid we will not trust completely. Not yet, anyway.”, my source replied.






November 2, 2009 at 11:47 am
jeffery kitingan made wrong political decision when he thinks that PKR can give what UMNO can’t. simple mistake repeating again and again by many local politician. it makes me wonder if they they really want to fight for the sabahan or just for their own pocket money?
sabah really running out of good and credibility politician. most sabahan don’t really like go into political stages as this kind of career only for those who crooked and wicked. to be in political stages, one has to learn the same tricks that those into the streets gangster.
the “sikap acuh tidak achu” by PKR bring more harm than good to its party not just in sabah but generally whole malaysia. anwar should let the democratic process to choose who is the rightful leader to lead PKR in sabah if he still want the support for the local.
jeffery kitingan should stop depending on the malaya politician and start to gain local support if he true on his words. working with outside based party will bring more racial and religious mentality into this state and division among the race will be more greater. at the same time, jeffery kitingan should stop his party hopping habits because it will bring a wrong impression toward the people about the importance of becoming a good leader.
November 3, 2009 at 8:54 am
Please do not write off Dr Jeffrey just yet. He is a Sabah fighter for our rights. He was enticed to join PKR in October 2006 because he thought that Anwar could be trusted as far as Sabah rights are concerned. It is proven all of us were wrong including Dr. Jeffrey (please read the interview with him with Roy Goh, NST 01.11.09). Moreover, PKR was the only party which were capable of taking on giant UMNO in Sabah at the time. There were of course a couple of Sabah-based parties available but they were just mosquitoes as compared to UMNO.
Dr.Jeffrey has given us a valuable lesson in our political struggle for the Sabah cause one that has to be relentless, courageous and consistent no matter what, the end justifies the means and that is exactly Dr. Jeffrey has been doing for Sabah! (and Sarawak for that matter).
November 3, 2009 at 2:20 pm
yes, you’re right rockymountain. i agree with you that PKR is the only political party that can challenge UMNO at the moment. thou, there is a price to pay don’t you know. even PKR is a strong party to challenge UMNO, it is not a party that good for sabahan.
we don’t need some party to challenge UMNO but a party that can fight for sabahan benefits. the only way to do that is to get a sabahan with sabahan based party. jeffery kitingan can be the person to be but his political strategy make us sabahan feel uncomfortable and make us think if he really “THE ONE”.
PKR has not yet proven to the sabahan that they is “THE ONE” party. even thou PKR can fight the UMNO but most of still has the ultramalay (ketuanan melayu) mentality. sabahan need no this kind of thinking in here where once upon a time, we can sat together on a same table and enjoy each other food without worrying race and religious issues.
we’re not writing off jeffery kitingan yet, but now he is not really a convincing person. anwar in another hand not helping at all by his act of “god hands” in sabah PKR admin. as a democratic party, anwar should trust and let democracy run its flow as he did preach. by handpick a chief it look and feel like UMNO again.
November 2, 2009 at 12:00 pm
They would want the type and size of shoes to fit their own feet. It needed a inter-dependent party working relationship and based on strong and common values, not one that antagonises another. Typical of umno objective.
November 2, 2009 at 3:07 pm
Goodness, Jeffrey Kittingan should resign from politics altogether! How many more times does he need to hop to realise he is no good at politics let alone a leader?
A good leader needs to be committed, peserve and responsible but the guy does not seem to have it nor the cut to be one. Yes, he riled up his former boss the PKR leader Anwar big time but that does not mean I agree with the kind of remarks Anwar had for him, it was uncalled for. But then Jeffrey needs to know it’s time he call it quits and make way for younger aspiring leaders for the sake of Sabah and Malaysia.
November 2, 2009 at 5:57 pm
These pkr (lower case deliberate) idiots must be dreaming if they think they can unseat BN at the next elections with all these self interests taking the forefront.
November 2, 2009 at 10:03 pm
Let us just stop talking about Dr. Jeffrey, Ansari or any old timers in PKR. As a PKR supporter, we should be talking about what are the plans for tommorow espcially on how to re-organise, rise from the ashes because of fire started by these few old timers. A new rejuvenated PKR and PR should be talking about its plans, its mission and its goals for Sabah. Not why there is crisis – these crisis is purely for the political survivial of Jeffrey, Ansari and the rest of their supporters. Just reorganise PKR with totally fresh and new people that would be the way. Immediately, PKR must then make things happen as the Elections is just a year or two from now.
As for some of the commentator who are not residing in Sabah, I urge you and Zaid Ibrahim to seriously go to Sabah incognito of course and listen to what the majority of Sabahans think about Jeffrey, Ansari and their respective cohorts. Jeffrey is popular only amongst the trouble makers of Sabah Politics – all loud but empty, really. Ansari on the hand is someone who has been standing as a candidate so many times that you ought to think there is law or policy against that. So commentators, the new generation – the fresh and the untainted ones is the answer for Sabah and Sarawak and not these few who have obviously media sought and expanded on a storm in a tea cup fact.
Reality unfortunately bites and again I urge you Harris Ibrahim, Zaid Ibrahim and other commentators to go to Sabah, Look, listen and learn about the truth on whether these guys are popular or not. I bet that you will realise that these flers are only loud and media exploting people only. If these guys are the answer to PKR or the opposition then we are in deep shit. So just do it man, listen to truth on ground and incognito so you will hear the gospel truth on who this Dr. Jef, Ansari and the rest are.
The future should be decided by the young.
November 3, 2009 at 9:05 am
My Choice said: The future should be decided by the young.
How young are you My Choice? 18 years old? Go ahead and join politics in Sabah if you are a Sabahan and you will know exactly how politics are run in Sabah especially when UMNO have a direct control over anything in Sabah to the extent that the people are suffocated. But I believe you are UMNO cyber trooper, you sound like one!!
November 3, 2009 at 11:04 pm
Oh yar RockyMountain, just go ahead and call me an UMNO cybertrooper. PKR is even stronger without Dr. Jeffrey and Ansari. Suppressing the truth by swaying away the real facts about PKR and its appeal by so many in Sabah is just typical of guys who are idolising someone who has past his prime. As for joining politics, why not. Our youth and perseverance without asking or expecting any position but to make a difference in Sabah and Malaysia is utmost important and is valuable for the people of Sabah. So why not join? UMNO is crumbling but guys like you and Dr. Jeffrey and even Ansari and Christina are no longer relevant. It could be because we young people do not politicians who bickers and think that they speak for Sabah. Rather we want people who works for Sabah. That is my two cents on your comment RockyMountain man. DX generation
November 2, 2009 at 10:33 pm
Aiya…if Sabahans want UMNO then go ahead la…. Your choice who cares anyway!!!
November 2, 2009 at 10:47 pm
Najib has his dream: to destroy Pakatan in the next general election. How?
I predict that the BN court will keep postponing Anwar’s sodomy II case over and over again. This will tie down Anwar with uncertainty so that he will be distracted in his political struggle. This tactic has already taken its toll on the Pakatan because with a distracted Anwar, whatever problems that have been bedeviling the Pakatan will not get the prompt attention of Anwar. And when problems are not being tackled expeditiously, supporters will get disillusioned and will start to believe Najib’s magic. Within 18 months if Pakatan has not solved its teething problems by then, Najib will strike and decide to dissolve Parliament for a general election. And be certain, Pakatan will be routed.
November 3, 2009 at 11:40 am
the politics of sabah should be decided by sabahan. being tens of thousand miles away and not being on the ground among the sabahan grassroots, tends to cloud our analysis and decision on matters of sabah’s politics.
at this stage to minimised the already damaged relationship between pkr’s central leadership and sabah’s pkr leaders, some sort of autonomy should be give to sabah’s pkr to decide by themselves and for themselves. the idea of centralised control is now already passe. centralised control in a current complex and more individualised society tends to break the social cohesiveness of the society rather than strengthening it.
in fact, in the long run, sabah’s people should be given the right for self determination – whether they want to be with us in semenanjung or they want to merdeka.
November 3, 2009 at 11:42 am
the politics of sabah should be decided by sabahan. being tens of thousand miles away and not being on the ground among the sabahan grassroots, tends to cloud our analysis and decision on matters of sabah’s politics.
at this stage to minimised the already damaged relationship between pkr’s central leadership and sabah’s pkr leaders, some sort of autonomy should be given to sabah’s pkr to decide by themselves and for themselves. the idea of centralised control is now already passe. centralised control in a current complex and more individualised society tends to break the social cohesiveness of the society rather than strengthening it.
in fact, in the long run, sabah’s people should be given the right for self determination – whether they want to be with us in semenanjung or they want to merdeka.
November 3, 2009 at 6:04 pm
For all the mistake I made in life, I’m really glad I didn’t made one by joining pkr. The leaders are slowly but surely making me feel that they are “once umno forever umno”, just change the surface only.
I’m getting alot of that all to familiar feeling of ARROGANCE from them, and you find a lot of it from umno.
November 3, 2009 at 6:40 pm
My choice, you sounded like you knew the ‘gospel truth’ about Dr.Jeff and Ansari. Care to share them then? If not, pipe down.
Dr. Jeff is all loud but empty? hmm..I wonder why was he detained in ISA back then..for being loud but empty?
He may be a ‘frog’ in the political world but at least he is consistent with his struggle for Sabahan cause.
November 3, 2009 at 11:20 pm
Probably we will pipe down once your Dr. Jeff and Ansari retires out from Sabah. C’mon be honest, you need Dr. Jeff or Ansari to survive politically I guess. So I can’t blame your sorry state. By the way, why not ask Dr. Jeffrey what he said at the last PKR meeting… did he say he wanted the post or lead PKR or did he say, he left to the president and he will support the decision of the president. That appeared at the Daily Express lor … so what about that? we are not in the know but I am sure the gospel truth is in the minutes of the last PKR meeting before that Thamrin fler got appointed as the chairman. Better ask Dr. Jeff to clarify on record if he fought for his position or left it to the president as reported in the news right after the PKR meet with si Azmin.
As for his ISA Detention, look at the history man. He kowtowed as Senator thru PBRS and served Mahathir as a Deputy Minister (based on internet search ah). He went on to join AKAR and PBS and made some attempt to join the ‘evil’ UMNO all for the sake of what? survival lar….
Granted, Dr. Jeff is consistent on Sabah issue but inconsistent in his political ways. He truly believes that he is the answer to Sabah’s problem. Tak boleh lar ‘guong’, he should know that his time is up in Politics. Go and become KDCA boss lar.
Let the new blood come in fight out the coming battle. As posted in another reply, the strenght by the youth is we seek no position but seek to work as a unit for change for Sabah and bring the change to Semenanjung Malaysia.
An yeah, as for the “Frog” bit, mind your words man, it would be an insult to a frog. At least the frog serves an agricultural purpose. What can a Party hopper and politically inconsitent man do for Sabah. Goodness.
I repeat to RockyMountain and Guong, the change and chance to defeat UMNO and their servants (MCA, PBS, UPKO, PBRS, LDP yaadda yaada yaada) is for the total revamping of PKR Sabah. Thank goodness for Dr. Jeffrey’s impending departure and hopefully Ansari’s and CHristina’s. That will give Sabah’s opposition a chance to reorganise with DAP and SAPP. PKR should lead the change man. It will … so you and other Dr. Jeffrey’s supporters just go …. take it with stride and go lar….
ANyway
November 4, 2009 at 5:59 am
Is it 210 seats to contest and win in Parliament?
So why can’t up to 210 AABM be chosen (from a stand-by shortlist of suitable AABM-candidates) be called up to stand as Independents if needed at the next GE13 should the candidates fielded by PR and other parties appear to be of poor calibre and so unable to pass muster on the integrity standard?
Why be beholden or restricted to just two parties or two coalitions who unfortunately appear to be far more interested in playing the same sort of old, tired and clearly outdated empire-building political games?
“Imagine Power To The People” John Lennon.
November 7, 2009 at 8:28 pm
Harris,
You got all your material facts wrong. Please walk the streets in Kota Kinabalu. People rejoicing and celebrating that Dr Jeffrey and his cronies are leaving PKR and giving PKR Sabah a breathe of fresh air. It is boost to PKR Sabah that the price of frogs is hopping away to another party or to form his own party. But I doubt about forming any new party and Dr Jeffrey had no experience in running any political party by hiomself before. He just hopped from one to another party after causing havoc and damage. It is always the same pattern that he wanted to be number one and if he could not get what he wanted, he will attack the party and its leadership in thye name of fighting for state rights and 20 points andf so on and so forth. He is doint it again in PKR. No single political party from BN is brave enough to risk taking Dr Jefferey and his gang of advisors and schemers. Most of them had been his victim. Where Dr Jeffrey is, that is where the trouble is. It is just a matter of time. For PKR, it is a blessing in disguise that it happened now and now on the eve of the next general election. Just imagine, if it happens one month before the election. PKR will be forced to close shop and out of the race. I am happy for PKR Sabah. Now you can have a fresh start and move on without looking over your shoulder. I will celebrate tonight and buy my pals two round of beer. Harris, please wake up and stop sleep-walking just like Joe F of Malaysiakini who has been spining pages of gossips and rumour from his little room with an ulterior motive of destroying PKR and Anwar Ibrahim.
ls
November 8, 2009 at 4:00 pm
Please visit my blog to have a better understanding on whats happening in PKR Sabah.”CURE OR CASTRATE THE CANCEROUS GROWTH”..http://advocateviews.blogspot.com
Your sources are disillusioned as to the actual facts.
Cheers.
November 8, 2009 at 4:05 pm
PKR tidak akan tunduk kepada syarat Jeffery : Ahmad Thamrin,Ketua Perhubungan PKR Sabah.
Parti Keadilan Rakyat(PKR) tidak akan tunduk kepada syarat-syarat yang diletakan Datuk Dr.Jeffery Kitingan untuk terus kekal di dalam parti,kata Ketua Perhubungan PKR Sabah Ahmad Thamrin Zaini.
Thamrin yang kesal dengan tindakan mantan Naib Presiden PKR itu menyifatkan ia adalah tidak wajar sedangkan parti itu mempunyai salurannya sendiri yang memberikan ruang kepada ahlinya menggemukan sebarang cadangan.
“Semua perlu faham PKR adalah sebuah parti nasional yang beroperasi secara demokrasi,tidak ada orang yang lebih penting daripada parti itu sendiri….tindakan Jeffery membuat syrat seumpama itu hanya merumitkan keadaan sedangkan PKR membuka ruang yang luas untuk ahli bersuara dan membuat cadangan ,ada saluran dan peruntukan dalam parti,kita ada forum,majlis pimpinan pusat dan negeri kenapa baru disuarakan sekarang”, kata Thamrin yang dalam lawatan sulungnya ke Sandakan selepas menyandang jawatan Ketua Perhubungan PKR Sabah.
Tambahnya,kapasiti Jeffery yang menduduki saf utama dalam barisan PKR sepatutnya memberikan kelebihan untuknya bersuara dan membuat sebarang cadangan.
“Empat perkara itu boleh di lakukan dan disuarakan kerana sebelum ini beliau sendiri merupakan Naib Presiden PKR dan Biro Politik PKR Pusat yang merupakan jawatankuasa tertinggi dalam parti yang mempunyai hak menentukan keputusan,” tambahnya.
Beliau berkata demikian kepada pemberita ketika diminta mengulas kenyataan Dr.Jeffery yang meletakkan empat syarat kepada parti itu untuk dia kekal bersama parti berkenaan.
Empat syarat tersebut ialah,ibu pejabat parti perlu membuat pembaharuan dan memastikan perlantikan dibuat berdasarkan pemilihan;Ia perlu menghormati aspirasi rakyat; autonomi politik bagi operasi PKR di Sabah; dan parti itu perlu menubuhkan jawatankuasa bagi meneliti terma jawatankuasa antara-kerajaan berhubung penubuhan Malaysia dan kelemahannya.
Dalam pada itu,ketika diminta mengulas dakwaan sesetengah pihak yang mengatakan PKR sedang berhadapan dengan krisis dalaman,Thamrin berkata ianya merupakan satu proses biasa di dalam mana-mana parti.
“Keadaan seumpama ini ada baiknya ianya merupakan satu anjakan dalam memperbaiki dan memperkukuhkan parti itu sendiri,ini memperjelaskan kepada semua siapa yang sebenarnya akan berjuang atau dasar perjuangan parti”, katnya.