Lil Hummingbird caught up with me at the lay-by heading out of KL last night.
‘Jaya, Shar and Chee Seng are spot on’, he said.
‘Who is Jaya, Shar and Chee Seng? And correct about what?’, I asked
‘Damn! Don’t you read the comments on your own blog? Are you sure you’re the one who administers The People’s Parliament?
The Hindraf ban? The Utusan siege of Teresa? The Tabung Azan? Don’t imagine these to be unconnected!
Najib’s got so much dirt that’s chugging out on the conveyor belt that he desperately needs a diversion.
And he needs to portray himself as the champion of the Malays and Islam, in the hope that the Malays that get taken in with the the spectre being conjured by UMNO of Islam/Malay bashing, will gloss over the reports coming out of Najib’s misdeeds.
Any adverse reaction by Hindraf to the ban will play into the hands of Najib’s boys .
Now’s the time for Hindraf to show their worth in planning the end of the oppressors. No need to show bravery on the streets. Makkal Sakti goes beyond that’
‘Surely you don’t expect Hindraf to just sit at home and do nothing?’, I asked.
‘They went to two Raya open houses, didn’t they? They were badly treated at PWTC but were well received at Anwar’s house, weren’t they? So throw their fullest support behind Pakatan now. That’s not doing nothing! That’s working smart’, he replied, his tone revealing a growing impatience at my question.
‘What you’re saying is Hindraf should pin their hopes on Pakatan forming the federal government so that the ban comes to nought? Is that going to happen any time soon?’
‘Very soon’.
____________________________________________________________
The comments by Jaya, Shar101 and Chee Seng reproduced below.
Jaya :
Banning Hindraf is a “smoke screen” to divert the nation’s attention from the ‘private sms’ and ‘public Eurocopter’!!
Only hope Hindraf’s does not fall into the ‘trap’ by responding as they ‘expect’ the reaction to be!
Need for a rational but strategic response is paramount.
__________________________________
Shar101:
Never mind the legal technicalities, bro.
It’s become obvious the authorities did not bother to heed Hindraf’s call nor did they provide a proper avenue for Hindraf to channel their grievances.
Militant UMNO needs a bogeyman.
In Hindraf, they found one or putting it another way, the UMNO-led BN government and the MSM have manipulated/reported events since Nov ’07 to paint Hindraf as such.
Things will get worse now.
Hindraf going ‘underground’ will create opportunities for the powers that be to set up state-organised covert groups masquerading as Hindraf to spread chaos.
Unless AI and PR have better options.
We seriously need a political solution to avert a social disaster from happening. Question is – Will AI take the lead?
________________________________
Chee Seng :
Is this a strategy to try and incite another May 13 or Ops Lalang?
Looks like it. Close observers of Malaysian politics have sensed a shift in the political climate since Dollah announced he decided not to seek re-election. The racism displayed by UMNO is no longer random. There seems to be more cohesion and focus in its expression.
It’s reminiscent of Ops Lalang i.e. a racially-charged scenario engineered by Mahathir who then swooped down on dissenters. Both situations also occurred when UMNO’s grip on power was under threat. Both situations cowed the nation into submission and allowed UMNO to weasel their way to a stronger grip on the nation.
It would seem that today the strategy has not changed, but tactics are a little more refined this time. Not because UMNO has become smarter, but because of their clumsy moves since March 8, they have to tread more carefully.
And since Najib, Muhyiddin and Mahathir seems to be one big happy family now, it’s pretty obvious Mahathir is calling the plays in the game.
So if we interpret everything that’s happening in our country now through the assumption that it’s all building up Ops Lallang 2 or May 13 pt 2, the strategies employed becomes obvious:
Step 1. First neutralise the Generals of change – RPK and Anwar
Step 2. Then incite the Malays to fever pitch – using Ahmad Ismail, Utusan Melayu, Khir Toyo, etc to paint everything uttered by non-Malays as anti-Malay
Step 3. Antagonise non-Malays – blatantly lie about Teresa Kok, RPK, the Sin Chew reporter, demonise HINDRAF, rip up KTK’s photo, etc, etc, etc.
This is moving the pawns into position for battle!
The next logical step would be:
Step 4. Confound the lieutenants to eliminate the second-tier leadership of the movement for change.
This can be done by crackdown or distractions. Since they have seen the rakyat’s recent reaction to crackdown, distraction is the more likely strategy employed.
Is it being implemented now? I believe so.
Plenty of issues are being thrown out into the open that divert attention away from people’s clamour for change of govt have recently surfaced – Cabinet absent from Parliament, refusal to re-table Budget 2009, fuel price decrease, RPK’s trial postponement, Utusan’s spat with Teresa Kok, banning HINDRAF, rumours of Zul joining UMNO, etc etc etc.
This will throw up plenty of fires to keep the remaining civic leaders busy. So instead of a concentrated push for changing the BN govt, the people’s energy is diverted to defending and supporting RPK, Teresa Kok and HINDRAF and trying to make heads or tails of the whole plethora of senseless issues.
These issues cannot be interpreted or reasoned out because they are designed to be senseless! So while the PR & civic leadership are thus occupied, the real strategising is going on between TDM, Najib and Muhyiddin.
Step 5: Strike decisively – Shock and Awe
Dear friends, it’s been 7 months since the election and the BN/UMNO has not shown any inclination to change or reform. In fact, we see their position hardening against dissenters. Now that the unholy trinity is finally in charge, the game will be up very soon.
We need regime change in this country if we ever hope to see real reforms. And we need it more desperately than ever with the global recession bearing down on us. (One can only assume that the PM-to-be refuses to table a new budget because when recession hits this country, we’ll be too busy worrying about our rice bowl than regime change.)
Let’s not be distracted from that goal.
How can we play our part in all this?
Do not be drawn into their evil trap! Do not get angry by their actions/words – that’s exactly what they want! Do not flame websites or blogs with our reactions to their shenanigans. Do not counter their comments.
Let’s stay focused! Our leaders in Parliament and in civic society need all our support!
SH Tan
October 16, 2008
All:
Stay the course, tread the path of least resistance and keep the flame burning.
Cheers.
Pak Sako
October 16, 2008
I believe that responsible, progressive bloggers have a role to play in what you propose, Haris. Instead of highlighting flammable or sensational news and thereby playing to the tune of certain groups, I’d suggest that bloggers focus on raising on their blogs genuine policy issues that affect the rakyat. There is a whole panoply of such issues to address, for our country faces challenges on many fronts. And these challenges are not restricted to just headline economic or social issues, but also many other economic, social or even environmental “micro-issues”. Bloggers can enlighten the reader on facts and issues readers don’t know about by combining these with real issues on ground. The government and mainstream media do not bring these to the attention of the public nor address these in any earnest way. For example, one can be a bit proactive and write a piece juxtaposing the recent supply disruptions with the need to rehabilitate our major rivers, which have been highlighted in various reports as badly polluted (I hear of no action taken to restore the health of these rivers, at least not in the prime media).
sam
October 16, 2008
There goes that damn bird again…I beg to differ with those birdy views…its ol school political analysis there. Sure, there’s some ol school diversion tactics employed by certain gomen personalities but that’s not their common strategy. Cos they don have a common strategy. Too many factions in bn/umno to agree on a common strategy, so various personalities are employing a method political scientists call ‘keep quiet in the face of allegations and keep throwing stones in public’. What this means is that you don’t comment on allegations you cannot disprove, stay away from parliament debates and go on the offensive in other public forums at as many opposing targets as you can. It may be interpreted as diversionary tactics but the intent is essentially buying time till they get their house in order. A fortiori, the suggestions by birdy num num are misguided. We need to keep the pressure on…don’t give them the time they so desperately need.
And this pkr coming to power and solving all the problems… don’t hope lah, ideal if it can happen but unrealistic that it will happen…definitely not as soon as we want it…
Concrete suggestions – keep the pressure on…this may 13 phobia has to stop and both sides of the political fence needs to know that it won’t work again…
navinda
October 16, 2008
Hi Haris,
This confirms what I heard during the Hari Raya break.UMNO is planning to clamp down on opposition and the first target is HINDRAF. They will use Hindraf as the scapegoat to gain malay support which they had lost. Hindraf will be painted black and as anti malay, anti islam, anti nation, all with the aim of resurrecting malay support. In the process, members of Hindraf may be harmed physically and locked up to bring this ‘minority’ group in line. I believe Samy may be manipulated in this scheme. IT is an old trick, the chinese the victim the last time, and the indians will be picked on this time. Now is the time for all to show solidarity; the malays, chinese and indians have to stand together against this plot by UMNO.
navinda,
Hindraf must do its part by shifting its rhetoric away from communal lines.
Let the clarion call be for the emancipation of all marginalised
Farida
October 16, 2008
I remember when Haris was verbally bashed for his stand that Hindraf not go to the streets on its own as an ‘Indian’ grouping and his pleading that it go under the Anak Bangsa Malaysia grouping to avoid the ‘race’ issue which he was sure the authorities would capitalise on. Correct me, please, if I am wrong.
Sadly, recent history has proven Haris right.
su
October 16, 2008
Haris, off topic, but just wanted to get your view on the latest article in Malaysia-Today about Najib being a Hindu. I actually think it’s of bad taste, really. It could also spark some very harsh reactions from ‘the other side’. Already Malaysian Insider is saying that MT is turning racial. But I’m not sure about who’s handling Malaysia-Today now without RPK around.
Could you throw some light on this?
su,
Yes, read the article.
The style is somewhat like RPK’s, don’t you think?
Anyway, re-read the article. It does not appear to touch on Najib being a Hindu. More that of his dabbling in hocus-pocus mumbo-jumbo, I think.
Who’s handling MT now that RPK is in Kamunting? RPK says he wasn’t the one handling MT when he was still at large. So if that’s correct, must be the same person I guess.
My 2 sen.
ps. Your t-shirts should be with you next week. Sending you the Barisan Rakyat and the Boycott the MSM t-shirts as well.
These are my birthday gifts to you
bubble&squeak
October 16, 2008
Can Hindraf work on being more racially inclusive? They need to be seen as championing all human rights and not just Indian rights. Since they are not a registered society as such, why not rebrand under a new moniker and encourage non-Indians a voice?
Speaking for one race is old hat – the new order will be about speaking for all Malaysians. I also wish that PR would be able to dissolve into one but I guess it is still a pipedream. It’s a funny union that one, all and sundry united against a common enemy.
Hummingbird is right.
In my little fantasy I would like to see Hindraf sitiing down tight and happy with PAS on issues that are relevant to both and all. This can still happen. Tok Guru is still in control of his party. He is a reasonable man and a good and well respected Muslim. I am not Muslim but even I admire his stand.
DSAI and the PR alliance is a good bridge for this.
This Govt – their actions are all very ironic – I pity that the people still cannot see through it all.
AuntyG
October 16, 2008
We must all play our part by not being emotional. People power UNITE and fight the common enemy.
With the present gomen, nothing is going to change at all, so help us God. Must admit its kinda frustrating that Anwar’s dateline keeps moving, but continue to hope is better than the no hope in the hopeless gomen!
So lil hummingbird, I buy your word …”very soon”
thepplway
October 16, 2008
teach us what should …in the human right stand.
moral…em…yes korek,korek …yes..
I hope much more malay in the sense of human right and adil voice out that Hindraf movement never against malay
Please say it .
lilian
October 16, 2008
You’re right, Haris. Hindraf should shift its rhetoric away from communal lines. Likewise, may I suggest that we give name and faces to the rest of the ISA detainees, most of them are Malays. I know RPK and Hindraf names deserved to be mentioned often, for their sacrifice, but we can bring our fight to all Malaysians if the rest of the detainees are made known, and not just “the rest of the ISA detainees”. Someone once commented (don’t remember which blog)that the rest of the detainees will be soon forgotten once RPK and Hindraf are released. Let’s show it otherwise by given the rest of the detainees name and faces.
ALEX
October 16, 2008
Bro,
I agree. Time for a quick refresher by someone on Ghandi’s ‘Satyagraha’ or Non Violent Protest ideas. That should checkmate them.
When the British used horses to charge Ghandi and his supporters, they all lay down flat on the ground – close together. Horses do not stomp on people lying down.
I really love that little line in that letter to the ADUN about the Masjid in Puchong which said, ‘terlebih dahulu kami minta maaf jika salah sebut atau silap kata etc’.
Thats how to disarm them.
Start everything with : ‘Terlebih dahulu kami ingin minta maaf jika kami tersilap sebut atau tersalah cakap. Maklumlah sebahagian dpd kami adalah pendatang yang menumpang. Maka kami merayu keperihatinan ketuanan TUAN’ or something like that.
Turn down the volume but turn up the heat.
Malaysianatheart
October 16, 2008
Hindraf is caught in a web of its own making. Several months ago I had suggested to Waytha Moorthy in London that he must re-brand Hindraf. Its far too communal. However, it seems that they fear losing the support of the multitudes that made Hindraf possible. And they lack ideas about how they ought to re-brand. In fact, even within the Indian community, there is a sense of unease about Hindraf’s clarion call.
It is now an opprtune time for Waytha and gang to re-brand. They have demonised Hindraf and “declared it illegal”. So if now Hindraf disappears from the face of the earth – and re-emerges almost immediately as something else – what will the desperado UMNO morons have to demonise or declare as illegal? In fact they will be at a complete loss. They will no longer have a whipping boy!
Come on Moorthy – lets show these morons that WE LISTEN to the rakyat. If the Rakyat want Hindraf to change or reform – then we will. Come out with a press statement that due to popular demand, Hindraf has been disbanded! However, Moorthy will be setting up a new front to tackle ethnic marginalization – including the non-malay bumis in East Malaysia??? Something to that effect. No longer marginalization of Indians – but ethnic marginalization.
All in all what we need to do is remove fodder that UMNO now have to keep shifting the Rakyat’s attention. If Waytha Moorthy comes out and declares that Hindraf has been disbanded – well hopefully that will be the end of UMNO being able to whip up racial sentiments. Of course they are going to accuse Moothy and gang of misleading the people, and that they are lying, that they have not in fact disbanded etc – but hey, they will again come out looking quite foolish. And no one is going to buy their rhetoric.
Think about it.
Reniv
October 16, 2008
BAN HINDRAF??!!!?? HINDRAF IS NOT A SOCIETY, NOT A POLITICAL PARTY NEITHER IS A MOVEMENT. HINDRAF IS ABOUT RAISING CONSCIENTIOUS AWARENESS THAT IS HAPPENING TO MARGINISED MALAYSIANS. HOW IN THE HELL CAN ALBAR BAN SOMETHING THAT WAS MADE AWARE OF? WE SHOULD NEVER THINK HINDRAF AS A COMMUNAL THING JUST BECAUSE THEIR LEADERS ARE OF INDIANS ORIGIN BUT OF MALAYSIANS.
Helen Ang
October 16, 2008
Haris,
Your ‘lil hummingbird’ has been wrong times before.
chengho
October 16, 2008
people power, makkal sakthi not the same with Ketuanan Melayu? why u said Ketuanan Melayu racist when Makkal Sakthi is not? not all indian is hindu? respect democratic system Majority Rule..
Palaniappan
October 16, 2008
Stay calm and stay cunning. Don’t react. For now.
Well said. I hope HINDRAF supporters heed this advice. BN (Read UMNO)will resort to all sorts of dirty tactics to provoke and please don’t fall into their trap. Patience is a virtue and hopefully things will change soon, I mean, PR takeover of the government. Until then please don’t do anything which will thwart PR’s plan.
chris chong
October 16, 2008
still waiting the new government…
almostrich
October 16, 2008
Dei ChengHO (bikin malu real cheng ho only!) You said
people power, makkal sakthi not the same with Ketuanan Melayu? why u said Ketuanan Melayu racist when Makkal Sakthi is not? not all indian is hindu? respect democratic system Majority Rule..
Ayoyo dungu boy! Makkal Sakthi means PEOPLE POWER in TAMIL NOT HINDU POWER OKAY?
PEOPLE POWER means all Malaysian People lah…not just Indians lucky for you the Indians are doing the tough job (as usual) for non Indians to comment intellectually and reap the fruit if successful, condem if not. Parasites or what?
pm
October 16, 2008
Hindraf must rebrand and not even to mention the word Hindraf at all in any gathering. It has been infiltrated.
Haris, Good advice..no street demonstration etc or any large gathering. They are just waiting for the time to pick up who they think are the leaders…slightest excuse to bash them up.
today
October 16, 2008
YESSSS!!!!Stay calm,stay cunning and stay on course!!!Don’t be duped!!!
Steven
October 16, 2008
A Chinese saying: use retreat as attack! Rationality is the keyword in this time of political uncertainty. If we believe strong enough to unite as one people, victory shall prevail in the end! Let’s buy time…2012 is not that far off!
futurist
October 16, 2008
In our circle of friends, there are bound to be some who would begin to react angrily. We should pacify them to wait for the best opportunity to act.
Slow and steadily, we should be able to achieve our objective. Didn’t we start with 0308?
Jit Dharma
October 16, 2008
Abang Haris,
Steam is coming out my ears!!
But you are Korek,Korek,Korek.
Hindraf is a state of mind, maan, and even
you are a member. Of course.So am I and I was’nt
till 2 days ago. Al-bozo should pull his head
out of his ass.
Humble voice
October 16, 2008
I agree with you Haris. Judging by the amount of explosive secrets that got leaked out, it does look to me that there are elements within BN who are more desparate to see Najib sink than us, the rakyat. This is time to sit back to watch the drama unfold while conserving our strength.
Ben
October 16, 2008
Don’t let the recent chain of events take the wind out of your sails. Stay the course and hold the ship of change steady. Don’t sail too close to the winds. Slow and steady wins the race to change which armno warlords are so afraid of.
We are on course.
Mag M
October 16, 2008
I wish that more Malays would come out to defend Hindraf and all ISA detainees instead of being brainwashed by UMNO who wants to divide the Malays and the non-Malays. The way things are going in this country is really sad.
Concerned
October 17, 2008
I think there’s another diversion coming from Gerakan’s Tan Lian Ho’s remarks about all of us are immigrants, deliberately or not.
By the way, I just read a comment on Malaysia Today’s “O Guruji, kemana kau pergi?” by someone being in Paris doing some investigation. It’s very unwise for him to expose where n what he’s doing now.
Please advise him not to expose what he’s doing prematurely. At least not until he has finished the mission and left where he is. I can’t post in MT cos m not registered.
The enemy is too powerful n too much is at stake here. They have the means to do nasty things even in Paris.
PLEASE ADVISE HIM. THANKS!
Concerned
October 17, 2008
I think there’s another diversion coming from Gerakan’s Tan Lian Ho’s remarks about all of us being immigrants, deliberately or not.
By the way, I just read a comment on Malaysia Today’s “O Guruji, kemana kau pergi?” by someone being in Paris doing some investigation. It’s very unwise for him to expose where n what he’s doing now.
Please advise him not to expose what he’s doing prematurely. At least not until he has finished the mission and left where he is. I can’t post in MT cos m not registered.
The enemy is too powerful n too much is at stake here. They have the means to do nasty things even in Paris.
PLEASE ADVISE HIM. THANKS!
anna brella
October 17, 2008
In my view, there is no need at all to disband HIndraf or any other human activist grouping of people fighting for a just cause which is for the common GOOD.
It just happens that at present, the majority of the people who are in Hindraf happen to be Malaysians who are from the Indian ethnic community.
What is needed is for more Malaysians from other ethnic communities and groupings to come together and join hands with Hindraf and stand shoulder to shoulder with them in a just fight to end all unfair and unjust marginalisation of ALL Malaysians for the common good of ALL.
So the more UMNO/BN tries to divide to rule, the more YOU/RAKYAT must stand up and unite to make them fail.
It’s that simple really – YOU just need to see it that’s all!
“Imagine Power To The People” John Lennon.
Fair Justice
October 17, 2008
To be very honest, HINRAF leadership has not been very wise on many occasions. Sure they caught some attention but the consequences have always been negative.
In the first place the name HINDRAF is a mistake, it’s too narrow n racial. INDRAF would be a better name or even better names that speak for the poor/oppressed/marginalized something like “Justice for Poor/Marginalized….” etc without any reference to race n religion. Also the word “Action” n “Rights” sounds too hardline n offensive to some.
Augustine
October 17, 2008
It’s too late for Malaysians to be passive so learn things the hard way! Banning HINDRAF is not a big thing as the scums in power have done worse things and will continue to do because we Malaysians are willing to suffer the continued insults and inequities heaped upon us non-UMNOputras. We can wait for the next election which these same people will not play fair especially when they know they are going to lose their power! What are we Malaysians going to do then, twiddle our thumbs still!! Good Luck!
bolehland resident
October 17, 2008
Desperate times need desperate measures….. UMNO is now desperate hence all the various “issues” they are raising. I can feel the repeat of the “pre operation lalang” situation arising. They are trying to create an air of “distrust” and trouble… naming scapegoats, using the media in whatever means they can, ISA, wrongful accusation, diversions… all to justify a MAJOR crackdown, so as to hide the guilt of the power hungry ruling elite. They have even co-erced the royalty with the current appointments of a “crony” into the judicial system as well as the release of “statements” by the royalty. I would not be surprised if they were to announce military law or marshall law.
It has been one major plot since the massive loss during the GE and the exposure of the abuses of power within the BN. We need to be smart, the stakes are getting higher, the only way to beat this is to remain united. Continue to pray for our country and support PR and Anwar. Continue to petition our current leaders, write to Amnesty International, write about the injustices in our country and broadcast it online. Raise awareness about our problems in Malaysia so pressure can be applied on our leaders to enact change.
DO NOT BLAME HINDRAF!!! That is basically what they want us to do… Blaming each other who are against the current regime will only weaken our unity and break our fighting spirit. As long as we see the lies being propagated by the BN as what they really are – LIES, then we will continue support the final cause which is a new Malaysia.
Balan
October 20, 2008
Stay calm,stay cunning and stay on course!!!Don’t be duped!!! by HINDRAF and their foolish leader’s.
Everyone including Pakatan Leaders appears to be defending HINDRAF not knowing what exactly they stand for.
Have anyone read their Memorandum,speeches or attended their gathering. It’s full of racially motivated rhetorics designed to stoke the emotions of Indian Malaysians.
Being one myself, knowing Indian malaysian susceptibility to sucumb to emotions without thinking, I can understand why they have large followers.
My take on HINDRAF, from Indian Malaysian point of view, widely covered in Aug/Sept/Oct Archive in my blog
Non-Indian Malaysians should read this to understand better issues brought about by Indians themselves before slamming any party.
http://balankumarpremakumaran.blogspot.com/