On 5th April, last year, two of the Hindraf 5, Ganabatirau and Kengadharan, were released from their ISA detention at Kamunting. Conditions were attached to their release.
A little over a month later, on 9th May, Uthaya and the other two were also released.
Manoharan and Vasantharao signed papers upon their release, attaching conditions to the same. Uthaya refused to sign anything. In fact, he refused to leave Kamunting if his release was to be subject to conditions. Finally, the authorities at Kamunting had to forcibly remove Uthaya from Kamunting, without him having signed any papers.
A year and a half earlier, just before the five were detained under the ISA, the authorities unleashed news that Hindraf had links with the Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam (LTTE), against a backdrop of calls, since the Hindraf rally of 25th November, that the ISA be used on the Hindraf leaders.
“Of late there have been indications that Hindraf is trying to seek support and help from terrorist groups” , Malaysiakini reported IGP Musa as saying, on 6th December, 2007.
The next day, Prof Ramasamy, the present Deputy Chief Minister, who had served on the Constitutional Affairs Committee of LTTE to draft proposals for an interim administration in Sri Lanka’s northeast in 2003, rubbished the IGP’s assertions.
“Don’t bring terrorism into this, because there is no link. There is no LTTE involvement. Look at the Indian problem and find a way to resolve it. That’s all. What does this have to do with the LTTE? Nothing. By trying to link them with terrorism, they’re trying to demonise Hindraf. It’s a well known smear campaign to sidestep resolving a problem. It’s utter nonsense, and there’s no basis for it. There is no LTTE support. LTTE itself needs support. What support can they give us? They themselves are appealing to the Tamil diaspora in Europe and US. We don’t need their support. This is a Malaysian problem” , Malaysiakini reported Ramasamy as saying.
On 8th December, Pak lah was reported as saying of the Hindraf leaders and the reports of their terrorist links, that the “ISA is an option. I will decide when the time is right. If they are deemed as a threat to national security we will know what to do”.
5 days later, all 5 were detained under the ISA and were sent off to Kamunting pursuant to two-year detention orders signed by Pak lah.
It would appear from a Malaysiakini report dated 21st December, 2007 that of the 5, only Uthaya had stated in his detention order as a ground for his detention, his having links with the LTTE.
Now, interestingly, on the day that Ganabatirau and Kengadharan were released, the man who signed their detention orders, Pak Lah was quoted as saying of Najib’s decision to release them that “It is good decision. A good move. I am sure the time has come for them to be released, so he released them”.
The time had come to release them?
Why?
They had been rehabilitated?
Had the time then also come to release Uthaya because he had been rehabilitated, had severed all ties with the LTTE and was no longer a threat to national security, if, indeed, ever he was?
Not a word on this from the authorities.
No appearing live on TV, like Abdullah Ahmad in 1975, or Al-Arqam’s Ashaari in 1994, to recant and repent publicly.
And, to-date, not a shred of evidence to substantiate their claim of terrorist links.
The threat to national security magically disappeared and, to quote Pak Lah, the time had come. It would be a good move.
This last week, the spectre of terrorism and national security under threat has reared its ugly face again.
This time, it’s militant elements in our universities, so the story goes.
On 15th June, Muhyiddin was reported by Malaysiakini as saying that ‘university and institutions of higher learning will be summoned to meet with the police over reports that the terror group Jemaah Islamiah (JI) is drawing young campus students into their movement’ and that ‘the government will allow the police to handle this matter and take all necessary action against the group if the allegations were true’.
The same report had it that the IGP had said earlier that JI was luring students into its movement via ceramahs that touch on the jihad (holy struggle) and inviting them to join militants abroad.
In the days that followed these statements by the IGP and the DPM, the mainstream media was ablaze with news of how our university students are at serious risk of being manipulated and lured into terrorism by those who may have infiltrated their ranks or, worse yet, the lecturing staff of our universities.
On 17th June, The Straits Times carried news of a terror plot to blow up places of worship in Penang and Selangor that was foiled in January this year by the arrest of 9 foreigners and a local. The 9 have since been deported.
The same day, another report in The New Straits Times carried Najib’s call to the authorities to step up their efforts to prevent extremist ideology from infiltrating the nations’ campuses, adding that intelligence reports would be collected and analysed to ensure that such groups would not be able to influence the students and other people.
The same report alluded to an earlier re3port that police were monitoring students at two universities believed to be spreading their religious ideology to other students.
Interestingly, I had received information round about this time that university students who were suspected of being involved in recent by-elections were under close surveillence by the police authorities.
Were the authorities looking at a way to clamp down on what many see as an increased activism amongst student bodies and movements? Were they looking to justify maintaining the strictures of the University And University Colleges Act, 1976, in particular section 15(5)(a), now under challenge in the Kuala Lumpur High Court?
Were we seeing the ‘smear campaign’ that Prof Ramasamy spoke of unfolding again?
On 18th June, The New Straits Times now carried a report that the ‘infiltration of terror groups into local universities is only the tip of the iceberg’, that the ‘al-Qaeda-backed group in the country has spread its tentacles into mosques and several non-governmental organisations’ and that the ‘group was trying to recruit more members, especially in Penang and Selangor, where it had plans to blow up places of worship in the two states’.
Another report in The New Straits Times of the same day, perhaps, gave a glimpse of what is to come, reporting the formation of a special committee headed by the Higher Education Minister and comprising representatives of the universities and police, to curb the infiltration of extremists into local universities. Minister Khaled Nordin was reported as saying that whilst the problem had not reached the “critical level” yet, swift action was needed to ensure local universities did not become a breeding ground for extremists.
The next day, The New Straits Times reported that there would be tighter security at places of worship, naming the Kek Lok Si Temple in Penang and the Sri Subramaniar Swamy Devasthanam temple in Batu Caves as the places of worship that had been targetted by the JI, as previously reported.
A report in The News Straits Times of 20th June laid bare that university students were not the only target of the authorities. It now was clear that the teaching staff at the local universities might also soon feel the heat.
Not surprising, really, given what I hear from students about the encouragement they receive from tutors and lecturers to pursue their activist work.
Yesterday, APW reported Najib as insisting that Islamic militants posed a “real national threat” after many in opposition accused the government of playing up the arrests of nine foreign suspects as a political diversion, and then issued a warning to us.
“If people do not want to believe in such threats, they will regret it later when terror strikes” , Najib warned.
The problem is one of credibility.
No one believes the government anymore.
On just about anything.
I certainly never believed the yarn about Hindraf or Uthaya having links with the LTTE.
And I find it hard to believe that UMNO was not in any way howsoever connected with the burning of the churches in early January.
So the only terror strikes that I will be looking out for will be thst which UMNO and its cohorts may try to engineer to strike fear in us.
The immediate question on my mind is where is all this ‘terrorist smear campaigning’ leading up to?
Are we looking at a foundation being laid for an Ops Lalang repeat?
If so, how far will the net be cast?
More importantly, how will the rest of civil society react?
hurricaneMax
June 22, 2010
a simpleton conspiracy:
– a ‘clampdown’ on JI or any ultra-islamist involvement is to puppetshow the west that ‘Yes, we are sorry. we were lax and relax about middle eastern arrivals, that these ultras took advantage of our famed hospitality’ to plan dastardly act against the west…
– a bombing campaign against other than islam, worship places is’real’ and only the Barisan leadership under Najib and the loyal pdrm can protect you ungrateful ‘pendatangs’…
– clampdown against the activists is yet another shadowy act lah.
Habib RAK
June 22, 2010
Bro, sorry off topic. We have a new radioactive plant in the making in Gebeng, Pahang. Please read Anil’s blog for details.
http://anilnetto.com/accountability/aussie-firm-builds-rare-earth-plant-in-kuantan/
Dr Who
June 23, 2010
Just another flanking attack by the gomen to lend credibility (using fear tactics)to draw-up more repressive laws so that they can stamp their authority to control students in local universities. This is related to the recent case involving 4 local uni students who attended the recent Ulu Selangor by-election.
Our gomen wants to nuture YES-men graduates who cannot question but supports blindly what the gomen does. If our universities produces ‘thinking’ graduates, our gomen will be in deep-shit !
anna brella
June 23, 2010
More farce?
Well, the barbarians are no longer at those gates I believe because they are now inside YOUR perimeter walls.
They are there with YOU because YOU let the in everywhere, so since YOU opened the gates and let them in everywhere, YOU now have to put it all right if YOU don’t like what the barbarians have done or are doing to YOU now.
So no choice now I am afraid but to stand firm and be smart and see through all the cheap barbarian antics and tactics, which as you know are only done and put on as a front to scare YOU and create confusion with the usual fear, scare and rumour-mongering so that they, the barbarians that YOU let in, can carry on pretending to take care of YOU (falsely) and protect YOU (falsely) from all those other non-existent and not at all really scary “terrorists” and “devils” and “deep blue seas” and other such false “bogeys” out who may only potentially be out there outside of YOUR gates.
So, wake up, stand firm with that spine and backbone of yours, smell the flowers, listen to the birds and the bees, look at the stars (real ones in the sky and not garbage astrology I hasten to add) and smile through all the manipulative forked-tongue talk and strategic web-spinning by the UMNO/BN wihios* and niathas** to keep YOU still conveniently doped, lulled, trapped, docile and dare I say, stupid?
“Imagine Power To The People” John Lennon.
*wihio = spider in Cheyenne
**niatha = same thing in Arapaho
Patrick Anek Uren
June 23, 2010
Why terrorists “in Selangor” and “Penang”? Is there other connotation to the report? Could that lead to declaration of emergency and suspension of constitution and a rule by decree of Yang diertuan Agong in the offing? It smacks of political vendatta.
MalaysianinNewyork
June 23, 2010
Harris,
You must be naive to think that individual Malaysians cannot smell the rat on how the government continues to hoodwink the public.In this episode, Najib definitely takes the cue from APCO. See this
http://ccrjustice.org/holder-v-humanitarian-law-project
Trust me not even 1% of our ardent fans wil have the time to look at this nor understand what this is about. Actually they might have a fright and abandone you as abstractions of state and political forces seem to dictate.
All of them including me are wanting to shout all we want in the cyber world and let the other fight the battle. We all can be articulate and know how it is in a cyber world, but the real action starts, when we, including me actually spend some time for a social cause in the field and that can only materialize when we don’t feign the waltz on what is popular but what is the reality and truth and what we can do about it rather than talk, talk and talk endlessly. No offense people, just an observation.
Sharing
June 24, 2010
Something can be done, if and only if, the elements – the mentality, the culture, the system, etc..are running with Rules and Regulations to be observed in common among the parties. Via personally experiences, NONE is available in Malaysia.
The Constitution is already in a sort of “King in his New Clothes” with All kinds of BIAS to the People. The Judges and Courts are at ease to drop the Published Rules and so does the Government with their Client’s Chapters, or, the Acts on which they are given the Power but not regulated.
Chief Justice or Chief of High Court Judge or their Disciplinary Committee keep their eyes close on non-justice or lending a hand to victimize.
DB of the bar doing the same. Lawyers can easily take money from clients, drag and do no work with the extreme of cheating, with help from the Police/KUP/AG.
Very straight forwards Fraudulent case, such as Wangsa Baiduri “Condo” project delivered Apartment without THE facilities and the facilities turned into an Hotel, Subang Town Park not realised since 1960′ and now in private land title, etc.. and cannot even find a lawyer.
How many Humanity or Human Rights Lawyers had put forwards what are wrong with the Constitution?
Even Rights as a House Buyer, a Client of a Bank, a Client of Insurance, a victim of Violence are at the mercy of those WHO HAVE THE OBLIGATIONS TO SERVE OR PROTECT!!
Malaysia is run by Politics and not Laws. That’s the Basic!! So, Talk, Talk, Talk until the clock dropped!!
Thanks for the input!!
—————-
FYI, a bank
a) can charge the clienton expenses long after the card was reported stolen.
b) Interest within 3 months already more than the disputed amount.
c) The bank stopped all the cards and called the cardholder as defaulter when all are paid except the disputed amount.
d) the bank keeps silent and not answering on which clauses accounted as defaulted. Refuse to provide how the interest was calculated..
Six months had gone, their complaint department silent!! Same with Visa USA!!
Malaysia in its nutshell!!
MalaysianinNewyork
June 24, 2010
Totally understand your perspective. Let us continue to have hope but understand without faith, hope will not prevail for humanity.Faith is no politics, law or the usual mumbo jumbo, it is about you and me to recognize and do something about it without returns for the truth rather then hedging our individual position with our usual talk, talk and talk in platforms.
Sharing
June 25, 2010
http://www2.ohchr.org/english/law/lawyers.htm
Anywhere is the Malaysian Bar or Lawyers be able to comply with what are stipulated there?
If the Bar Talks and Not Walk, Lawyers get paid and flip-flop, or even assaulting clients without even be acted, Malaysia is NOWHERE be hoped at an Average International Standard. Or, be a country with Laws!!
ALL TALKS and NOT Walk!!
When the Chairman of the Bar took 1000 or more lawyers for a Walk for a Competent RCI on the Lingam Case but announcing “Give him a Chance” on arrival Putra. Is this a kind of Walk??
The Hope of Malaysia is not JUST by the Change of Ruling Parties, but, the availability of Ethical and Competent People in ALL WALKS OF LIFE with Rules and Regulations as well as the Mentalities to do so. The Professional have to lead. But, how many are Professional also in the sense of Ethnic?
A nice cup of Coffee,or,a sip of Old Whisky, then get onto a nice bed without “Walk & Talk” may be chance for a Sweet Dream!!
Open eyes and walk into Malaysian system (social, administration and Political) is a Nightmare!!
shafeek taff
June 23, 2010
Haris,
This is a clear indication that the umno gomen is using the APCO playbook which was (probably still is) used extensively by the American and British zionists.
We all know who APCO is linked to.
Bigjoe
June 23, 2010
Using a bogeyman has always been an UMNO/BN core skill. Mahathir made it an art-form. He used May 13, Soros, IMF, Singapore, Suqiu etc. What is so surprising about using JI for Najib.
The problem is no one really believed Mahathir when he used all his excuses. They went along with it either because it was futile to protest or it was practical to do so. Mahathir forced it by sheer power and delivering on economics.
The problem is Najib has no leverage. He neither have the same hegemonistic power nor has be delivered on much. He can’t pull off the bluff.
Anyone who plays poker knows that its a really bad idea to try and bluff if you don’t know what you are doing and Najib don’t know what he is doing..
chan ching
June 23, 2010
Those who burned Churches and Surau,are they terrorists?I am not surprise the next move of the govt is to ban blogging because it have been infiltrated by the terrorists!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Abil
June 23, 2010
There are some people including our former PM Tun Mahathir who presume that the bombing of the twin towers on 9/11 was engineered by U.S. as a pretext to waging a war on Irag by then President Bush. We cant discount possibility of terror threats to create an atmosphere where the fear factor will help the UMNO in elections.
barry
June 23, 2010
The only real terrorists I see in Malaysia are the ones in uniforms who are given the full authority to torture and murder innocent people mainly non-Malays especially Indians. And not forgetting the one particular leader in our present government who has been directly accused of murdering a Mongolian woman by the name of Altantuya.
Emmie
June 24, 2010
Absolutely right Barry
Malayimbabwe (formerly known as Malysia) ahs terrorists, absolutely! 99% of them are in UMNO.
shakuntala
June 23, 2010
We are back into the old refrain, battle for and control of our minds…that is why we are witnessing intellectual suppression.
Many thanks for your video clip on this subject Haris, ref: your blog on Kuburkan BN…timely and red-hot messages sung out with soul.
Great education from just one song.
Rabid
June 23, 2010
The Malaysian bombers in Indonesia did come from a certain local university, but we have to doubt the political will and clear thinking of our overlords in solving the problem. Now, university administrators may be coerced into “nominating” “suspected” terrorists, who will ultimately sign confessions.
shakuntala
June 23, 2010
It is good to be alert. As sensible Malaysians, we are.
There is no need to instill fear…by the use of the word terrorism.
People are asking for proof…so the BN government is duty bound to listen to the people.
….they need correct answers from the government, not sketchy hasty replies, especially as the warning against the likeihood of terrorism in this country sounds urgent and calls for responsible re-actions.
shar101
June 24, 2010
Haris,
Found these articles with reference to the arrests in January 2010 –
http://www.gamji.com/article8000/NEWS8989.htm
http://allafrica.com/stories/201001290204.html
Nothing was mentioned then about recruitment nor attempts to attack local targets.
Let’s also not forget that there was a U.S. travel advisory for Sabah during the same period –
http://thestar.com.my/news/story.asp?file=/2010/1/15/nation/20100115192234&sec=nation
Were the January ’10 arrests done to placate the U.S. bearing in mind that two F5E jet engines went missing and now, the same excercise has been re-jigged to suit local ‘political’ expediency?
After all, in the name of national security, the Home ministry will always deny any disclosures on foreign intel sources thereby shielding the BN administration from telling the truth to Malaysians.
Personally, I still think the ongoing Scorpene investigations by the French on DCNS is the underlying factor.
If Perimekar breaks, Najib’s toasted for sure.
shar101
June 24, 2010
More clarification today from GMI –
http://www.malaysiakini.com/news/135403
Who’s the one terrorizing? If not UMNO Baru?
Bigjoe
June 24, 2010
UMNO/BN have cried wolf far too many times and for too long, people don’t believe them even if its true.
komando
June 25, 2010
If there is any evidence that there is a real threat, go catch the buggers, charge them and hang them like you did to all the Al-Maunah bunch of crooks or Mutineers who went against the KING!
So be it, we would trust you and your very So Special branch can go find them all and put them down for good, do not just talk talk talk, nothing but cocks talking !
Show us the real stuff, proof it to the world like in Indonesia, go hunt them down and shoot them like dogs, no matter whether they are Ex-Menteri Besars or current Menteri Besars, or Ex-IGP’s!
DO IT DAMN IT !
fizli
June 26, 2010
You are just a self-centered anti-establishment. Nothing great !
Osama
June 26, 2010
I think Perkasa with the stupid arse hole frog and his big mouth is a bigger security threat to the nation than JI.
Perkasa is now totally irrelevant to Malaysian society as the Malays had unanimously dumped them as can be seen by the “Bangkit Melayu” rally. King Frog should realize that the Malays are much smarter today than previously and are not willing to allow themselves to be used as political capital to further the interests of a few! Even Mamakkutty cannot fool them anymore.
UMNO Baru has really cried wolves far too often, but, after the Kallimah Allah issue, cow head protest, burning of churches, arson attacks on mosques, pig heads found near the compounds of mosques, Malaysians had awakened and are so used to all these cheap tactics by UMNO Baru to scare the people. Infact, all these had made Malaysians more resilient and very much smarter to the political threats from within. It had reached a stage whereby all political statements by our leaders are seriously questioned. It is a serious problem, a CREDIBILITY problem for UMNO Baru, and thank you PERKASA and mamakutty.