By Helen Ang
_____________________________
Some thoughts on theSun’s spindoctoring discussed in Toss the Sun-block! Danger, danger, Sun-stroke …
Edmund Bon had summarised the implication of the survey findings which indicated that young Malaysians are increasingly becoming polarised. He commented that the underlying problems – “education policies, scholarship issues, quotas, both religious and racial policies” – would be better looked at than banking on ‘superficial’ national unity campaigns which merely scratch the surface.
One programme into which much money poured was the over-hyped Rakan Muda. I remember the snazzy and doubtless expensive ad campaign in mainstream media, both print and broadcast. And on TV, the rousing jingles touting the national youth programme. Whatever happened to Rakan Muda?
Back in end-2003 when National Service was launched, there was such a shortage of non-Malay trainers that Najib Razak who chaired the NS cabinet committee threatened to enlist the ‘Nons’ under the National Service Act. I wonder what the racial composition is now and if the trainers possess an adequate cultural sensitivity.
The organisation chart of the Jabatan Latihan Khidmat Negara online lists 17 office holders by name, of which 15 are Malay-Muslim (with bin/binti), with one Indian in Customer Service and one ‘Sulaiman Kho’ (Chinese-Muslim name possibly). Since NS is an Army-affiliated programme, doubtless Malays predominate throughout the hierarchy.
In national schools, non-Malay pupils and parents have complained about Little Mullah Napoleons. In NS, the girls are required to tutup aurat (cover up), fastening their shirt to the topmost button at the neck, or so a conscript released from the most recent batch told me. I observed the truth of that statement in my visit to camp on Open Day – the non-Malay girls were indeed obediently buttoned-up, whether wearing jungle fatigues, shirt or T-shirt (the 3 long-sleeve uniform sets).
In May 2004, Najib had promptly declared upon the completion of the first NS stint that it was “a resounding success”. The newspapers dutifully transcribed his words.
Freelance journalist Anil Netto, who does not write in Malaysian MSM, reported on May 4: “But most participants apparently don’t like it and there is widespread public unease over major and minor incidents, including violence, gangsterism and truancy.” http://www.atimes.com/atimes/Southeast_Asia/FE04Ae01.html
Najib’s cousin, Hishamuddin Hussein assured the public, “We do not want isolated untoward incidents to cloud public perceptions about the real potential of the programme. Although they were only minor hiccups, a review of the programme is important to prevent them from recurring.” (NST, May 1, 2004)
The ‘minor hiccups’ have ballooned to about 20 deaths, by some counts. The official NS website says nothing of this and therefore I cannot quote an official figure. Was there any ‘review’ as promised by the Education Minister? The anguish caused bereaved families continues unabated.
And what is ‘the real potential’ of the 3-month internment? To cook up patriotism in 3 minutes like instant noodles when 13 years of segregated schooling and deprived education opportunities would tend some otherwise?
My jaw dropped when I read the Wikipedia citation on National Service. Under its Nation Building module, Wiki says trainees are taught in the classroom on “loyalty towards the current government, Barisan Nasional”.
So the NS integrates Malaysian youth under the BN banner, eh? Oh sure, being told they’re ‘Wira’ (warrior boys) and ‘Wirawati’ (girls) in camp may well convince some of the teens that they’re not ‘Anak Tiri’ (stepchild).
At the end of the training, these youths will be absorbed into two different education streams. The non-bumi take the STPM route whereas the bumi enjoy the matriculation gateway, preferred critical courses, scholarships and other forms of support like special tutorials and lenient marking. In the meanwhile, the Education Ministry fudges on how apples are really oranges in Bolehland, and creatively spindle exam results and faculty ‘statistics’ for the unbelieving.
There is also the UEC (Unified Examination Certificate) which takes Chinese youth to Taiwan, Singapore dan lain-lain universities – something Namawee rapped about in ‘Negarakuku’ – but the cert not recognised in Malaysia.
For other qualified but excluded youngsters, there are always the private colleges. For the underprivileged, Malaysia thinks its fine that they sell pirated DVDs at the pasar malam or cell phones at shopping mall booths, I guess. These Bangsa Malaysia kids may love their country but does their country love them?
nmjg
April 23, 2008
Najib, Lee Lam Thye and others who initiated this National Service thing have caused so many innocent lives to be lost. This is definitely bad karma. They will have to repay back all their sins and debts for generations to come. Remember the curse of Mahsuri in Langkawi?
kinsyng
April 23, 2008
speaking of education in bolehland, that is exactly the reason why UM could produce a racist as a leader for its students’ union… what was his Indon name again?
yh
April 23, 2008
do they care about the deaths? Chairman Lee didnt even utter a word on the last death in April 2008. Instead, he came out speaking about the lack of resources in health check before the kids are sent to play russian roulette in response to a participant who gave birth while in national service. that shows how much he values about lifes of innocent and healthy malaysians who were sent to their early death.
I am still wondering how Najib and Lee Lam Thye sleep at night knowing fully well that more kids will perish in the program. Are they robots with no feelings at all to the sufferings of the bereaved families? Or Najib and Chairman Lee care more about cronies profits under the cover of national integration. Afterall, the yearly budget is no small meal at RM500 million. Only both of them can answer. As for me, I am inclined to believe the latter.
Scott Thong
April 23, 2008
Thanks for the inspiration for the 28th poster. Enjoy.
Malaysian Politics Motivational Posters
barry
April 23, 2008
I tell you, this NS thing is one big mistake cooked up by the BN govt. It serves no purpose other than to enrich the monkeys who get big fact contracts, ala direct-nego style. My son went through this programme, and came out, in his own words ‘more racist’ than before he went in. His friend shared the exact same view. I suspect these ‘trainers’ are basically the unemployed (rather, umemployable) graduates, who were taught to spew propaganda (hate evil America!). Trainees were severely punished if caught smoking, at the same time, the trainers were puffing away – what hypocrisy! At the end of the camp, my son walked out of his ‘imprisonment’ more bitter about life than before!
Scrap the whole bloody useless NS! If anything sort of training needs to be given, then it should start at primary schools.
kl
April 23, 2008
ooo but we need the NS! How else to spread the gravy from the gravy train? This NS scheme is throughout the country, perfect scheme to reward cronies from far and wide. Aisay, one or two deaths nevermindla, consider it a sacrifice for the country.
Afterall, as long as you aren’t connected to a certain party/group, or you don’t have strong anough cables …. you have only yourself to blame what.
Brainwashing for the party is ok what,.. we want allegience to the party! Country is secondary. All this tactical plays taken from the nazi playbook can’t be wrong….or is it?
My2cen
April 23, 2008
Barry,
The NS is No mistake as far as Najib is concerned – it is a wayang desinged to showcase their Boleh skills to bend the kids and also fill up his pockets being part of MinDef program! Only in Bolehland can C4-man and KerisMan cook up something so ridiculous and get so much taxpayers money to fund (and siphon-off) it!
rebel
April 23, 2008
I have made up my mind, if my child gets enlisted to NS, I will do anything possible for her not to attend the camp,even it means we have to leave the country. This child of mine is precious, no way I am going to send her to a hell hole where she will probably will not come out alive.
The govt or that Tan Sri can’t guarantee me anything and I am not willing to risk my child’s life. THey can put their own kids in there and suffer the consequences, oh no they wont do that cause their kids will be packed off to overseas for higher learning by then:)
rebel,
Don’t leave the country to avoid the NS for your child.
Live up to your name. Be a conscientious objector. Creatively try to challenge the order to attend NS, if need be through the courts, once the judicial reforms are in place.
raj raman
April 23, 2008
Haris,
I sure pack my 2 girls if this bn moron still in power.Well prepared for them until i pokai for their future.
Lee lam thye once i admired,but after he bacame barisan moron and under their pay check,he another moron like siva subramaniam of suhakam.( he never met uthayakumar but said the camp comander taken care of him.)One sided news.
Do you noticed,when other subject of public interest all malaysian in one voice,but comes to religion everyone shouting like me in your blogs.
Raj raman.SOMETIMES COOOL AND SOMETIMES GOES AMOK.anyway u can start charge me a ringgit for each time i blogs to your side.
My2cen
April 23, 2008
Rebel, instead of running away, why not start a campaign to stop the NS? What was started as a silly summer camp to brainwash the kids to glorify BN (and another money-making project for cronies), has turned out to be very deadly. In medicine, drs have a Motto, First do no harm. Here statistics have shown that there is a risk of death when a kid enlists in NS. And the statisctics tells us that this risk is increased over time. Thus it’s a damn good argument to stop this NS. In medicine, a drug that caused grave injury/side-effects and death will not be approved. Same argument here, a program that has been shown to cause death to apparently healthy kids should be scrapped.
My2cen,
Saya setuju.
Any other parents out there equally concerned like rebel?
Why not get together and plan a course of action to put a stop to this nonsense that was contrived just to enrich a few fat UMNO cats and at the same time indoctrinate kids with pro-BN crap?
Will make space in this blog to publicise your initiative.
Apa macam?
Haris, do you agree??
Discrimination69
April 23, 2008
Can anyone tell what are the statistics of kids from UMNO Supreme Council that attended NS? or from BN component parties? or are they all exempted or already overseas with western education or in boarding schools? maybe purposely not selected, “wink”!!
Discrimination69,
Good questions, man!
Anyone?
raj raman
April 23, 2008
lets me quess for you haris,
BN MORONS can always come out with statistic but can we believe them?
Second if BN MORON send theirs kids,i can tell you,the camp comander even will go to the extend to build a gold plated toilet for this moron kids.
RAJ RAMAN.I WONT EVENT BETS MY 2CENTS AND BELIEVE IN BN MORONS.(checkmate $2ringgit for u haris for my second comments 2 your blogs)
yh
April 23, 2008
haris
i am in. rebel, my2cen, lets start to work before another kid dies. my eldest is 12 years and have another 6 years before she will be send by lottery to play the russian roulette game.
**** lee lam thye and najib. before she suffers the risk of an early death, i better start to act. are you guys on?
rebel, my2cen, others?
yh
April 23, 2008
my2cen
i dont bother glorification of BN or PR. Thats not the importance. Its the kids’ lifes. Young innocent and healthy malaysians falling by the roadside while attending this killer program? must be nightmare for parents.
you think that lee fella care? he didnt even bother when a 18 year kid died in april. and a week later he came out lamenting the lack of medical staff to provide check ups in response to a particpant who gave birth while in the shit NS program.
Lee, may hell beckon you each time a young and innocent Malaysian drop dead during the NS program. and i pray very hard for that.
yh
April 23, 2008
haris
pardon my language. i am very stress up whenever i see a young innocent kid passed away for no good reasons. as for me and i believe for the majority of parents, our kids are our pride and joy. they are the ones that will carry the flags of our country in the future.
do mail me and I be there to participate and contribute to a stop to this killer program. ENOUGH IS ENOUGH before another innocent malaysian dies from this.
No worries. Let’s try and get this effort up and running
barry
April 24, 2008
I will bet my bottom dollar that NO UMNO child will be in this NS fiasco. In Malaysia, it’s just a phone call away from someone at the ‘party leadership’. Boleh!
I have a 16-year-old daughter who is due for this NS ‘lottery’ thing next year, and I am worried sick for her. In her case, she has atopic eczyma, a chronic case of skin problem. I am hoping to get her exempted on medical grounds. Btw, did I tell you that my son almost died at the camp in Tasis Cini due to a very severe allergy when he came in contact with some plants or insects in the jungles? Guess it’s bad genes from my side of the family. 😦
Whatever action you guys are planning to get rid of this ridiculous money-sucking exercise by the monkeys, please count me in!
Kathy
April 24, 2008
The idea of having NS is already wrong in its conception. We cannot foster patriotism in 3 months. It is built over the years. It is indeed sad to see another young life lost in this failed programme. I do agree that I would not want to let me children go through this programme as i treasure their life.
Those come up with the idea only wants to make money from it. Should look into their accounts books and see how they are spending the tax payers money.
Enough of segregration of education system – this has led Malaysia into disharmony and disunity. Can’t we just take away the unnecessary subjects like kajian tempatan and moral classes from the education system (while having civic class without the need to evaluate the children – like the old times). Language classes should be put in place in all schools. Guess the Education Minister have not fulfilled his promise from the earlier election.
Helen Ang
April 24, 2008
My2sen, Rebel, yh and others,
I can’t speak for the camps I’ve not visited but I’ve seen one dorm. The first sight of it hit me with shock as “How depressing!” They’re bunked about 20 beds in a purpose-built block.
Each trainee has a bed and small locker, ranged against the wall in 2 rows. Among the complaints: blankets not useable. A conscript brought own from home and every night did a swap; in the morning laying out the regulation issue blanket on the bed for the inspection.
Here are 2 letters published in Malaysiakini:
‘Don’t trust NS camp people’
http://www.malaysiakini.com/letters/81755
Prof Dr Mohamad Tajuddin Mohamad Rasdi, a parent whose children has completed NS, writes that he has closely followed the 20 deaths. He states: “… all of them, I believe, are caused by the carelessness and ‘don’t care’ attitude of the camp officers.”
Another letter from A Malaysian Parent says “our men in uniform sent overseas to hot spots on peace keeping missions are safer that our children sent to the National Service Programme.”
http://www.malaysiakini.com/letters/81824
And this is what the Sun-stroke paper reported Jan 3, 2007 on Lee Lam Thye’s response to a “logistics foul-up” that plagued NS. theSun reported: “Lee has also told the department’s director-general to conduct a post-mortem.” The ‘postmortem’ referred to concerns buses not turning up to ferry the kids to camp, and not corpses.
theSun report goes on: “Lee said he could resign and be accountable for the problem but this would not solve the problem. ‘I will not resign. On the contrary, I will do the best to ensure the programme is implemented smoothly and I will strive to regain the parents’ confidence that has worn thin as a result of the chaos’.”
To me the chaos is that Malaysian parents did not bring up their children alive and well for 18 years to suddenly perish at a 3-month camp.
tuahyong
April 24, 2008
tuahyong wrote…
Haris, I hope you can initiate some campaigns to “Mansuh LPKN” and save the government our taxpayers’ money and also the kids, others and mine from the “tiba-tiba maut” syndrome in isolated camps!
Save the money for subsidising prices of essential goods such as petrol, gas, rice, cooking oil,from spiralling and I would like to suggest in order for the prices of rice to be stable is to allow more players to import rice and not to be monopolise by Bernas only!!
Aiyoh!,PR seize the opportunity to be the Fed Government and scrap all this Be End programmes and better still to “korek,korek,korek” their misdeeds!!
rebel
April 24, 2008
Dear My2cen
The reason I said that we will have to leave this country if my child is enlisted in NS was because we have better support system in overseas than we have (as in my family). As a single parent working fulltime,occasionally any other extra jobs to earn addtional $$$$ and bringing up a child I can’t depend or even turn to put a hand out to anyone to help us,I am not complaining,I am proud to do it on my own and with the strength that GOd has given me. If that is running away for you so be it.I am only human and as a parent I will only look for the best interest and safety of my child.
To all: I am in to ensure we kick this NS programme out.what do we need to do?
Cheers
barry
April 24, 2008
My son nearly died in the Tasik Cini campsite due to the lack of medical attention. He had somehow come in touch with some insects or plants which caused severely allergic reactions (the worst part was when he had breathing difficulties). There was simply no doctor available at the entire site and the nearest hospital was about 1 hour away in Kuantan. Thankfully, the medic at the campsite, who was in the near state of panic gave him two shots of anti-hestimine to stabilise his condition. For us as parents, we can only thank our God that He answered our prayers to keep him alive.
For my 2nd child (daughter) who is due for this ‘NS lottery’ next year, we are simply preparing and hoping she doesn’t get called. She has severe atopic eczyma. Must be the bad genes from my side. 😦
Steve F.
April 24, 2008
Haris,
Count me in.
C
April 24, 2008
Yeah they don’t care and treasure the value of a life. I could hardly see any form of sincere apology and strong resolution for the case of deaths of NS trainees and other unpleasant cases. All they did is saving their own face with very hollow and little actions and widely polished their acts of reform sparklingly through the media. Speaking of wikipedia ( the online encyclopedia) , do take note the citation of Najib. ” Soaking it with blood” came out from his mouth and his intention ….I really don’t know how and what to say .
What will we get from the wikipedia known to the whole world in future? A cover-up or controversial massacre on those who doesn’t abide him.
We have murder case under his belt as a deputy. As a head , what will we have? More controversial murder cases till the statement become massacre? That time I really don’t know where to hide my face when I am abroad with foreigners asking me things about our leader.
I hope Malaysians tend not to be forgetful. Do remember that a fresh Malay auditor was murdered in Hong Kong in the early 90s. It’s a controversial murder and is unsolved. He is fresh in the field and because of doing his job professionally he became the white rat for others not to check the $$$ of govt-linked co. Is justice given to him?
barry
April 24, 2008
So, that’s one Mongolian woman by means of C4, and how many of our children to go? God, please help us!
My2cen
April 25, 2008
yh,
I am equally upset and stressed whenever I see an innocent live taken away in our country of plenty. I am more upset at the parents who mumble and grumble but keeps sending their kids to NS.
Kathy,
You’re spot-on! Isn’t it absurd that all our cabinet ministers put together cannot even comprehend it?
Helen,
I’ve studied and lived in malaysian boarding schools before. Depressing dorms are the norm, but can be overcome. Death is the issue. Something must be horribly wrong if Military training is safer the NS training! Worst this govt tolerates the death it has caused and has not taken steps to safeguard all the precious children. No accountabilty at all.
I have 10 nephews and nieces ranging from 4 plus to 17 yrs old. I would like to see them all grow up and mature into responsible and happy adults. The oldest boy may strike lottery next year, and I am worried as hell!! Yes, count me in to stop this program. Wasting our hard-earned money is bad enough, taking the lives of our children is UNforgivable.
Paul Warren
April 25, 2008
Helen, you need a lesson in decision making ala Barisan Nasional Government of Malaysia.
First: Find an excuse : So we have polarised teenagers coming out of school never given the opportunity to co-habit..ah..wrong word…to assimilate..thats asking too much..to play police and thief in school….that is enough…
Find a Solution: Get them together on an organised programme…
Still not good enough;
Most important thing to be achieved: Provide an excuse to drain out taxpayer’s money!…Ah..this is it..If they can convince themselves…who cares about convincing the people.
Give it credibility? Easy…that guy Lee Lum Thye owes it to them for the Tan Sri he has got…Use him la.
For the money to be made,what the hell..a few lives lost in the process? Cheap la..
Like as if the NS is such great wonder….
Malaysian Miracle.
cocky
April 24, 2009
Hitler also wanted to build a “master race”. The children of Germany were viewed by Hitler as his future hope for such a success. Children were also more naturally teachable and would therefore be more easily molded by Hitler than older adults. Many of these adults also remembered living under democracy, and therefore might not be so easily fooled by Hitler’s lies against democracy. Children could also be a future asset in his war efforts, since Germany was still a small country going up against the combined military forces of most of the world. These children could become his future soldiers and leaders of his “Third Reich”, an empire which was to last for a thousand years. – Hitlercontrol
Ever wonder why the old cocks are out there and making noises In Malaysia instead of the young ones, as against youths in more enlightened societies?
They remembered … !!! That in their times, there was a semblance of democracy and appreciation and honor for human dignity. In other words, the old days were great days!
To all the older Malaysians, let’s ask … Do you remember???
cocky
April 24, 2009
Lee Lam Tahi will like this – he also used NS Trainees for political purposes at Batang Ai Bye election …
[ “…preliminary observation report on the three by-elections, including Bukit Gantang and Bukit Selambau, that were held simultaneously on April 7, election watchdog Malaysians for Free and Fair Elections (Mafrel) claimed the trainees were “mobilised to rally for BN during the nomination day…” ] – http://ckcounterpunch.wordpress.com/